Do Whatever You Want,” the Cowboy Said — But the Apache Woman’s Next Words Changed Everything

Chapter 40

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

You tied me to that post, she said, and each word was clear, and each word cost her nothing now, because the cost had already been paid, in blood and in nights when she had lain awake listening to her own breathing and wondering whether anyone would come. "You did not tie a debt. You tied a woman. I was travelling to my brother's camp when your foreman and his men took my horse and my pack and left me in the sun to teach my people a lesson. There was no debt. There was no theft. There was only a man who wanted water that was not his, and who thought that fear would make it his."

Malloy opened his mouth, and then closed it, because Sheriff Bennett had stepped forward, and Bennett's voice, when it came, was the voice of a man who had done his work before he came to a boundary, and who did not need to bluff. "Mr. Greer," Bennett said, "Henry Doyle has made a statement in Copper Bend. He says you pressed him to sign a paper he knew was false, a paper that called Miss Naya a runaway bound to your outfit, and he says you threatened his store's credit if he refused. Doyle is not a brave man, Mr. Greer, but he is a truthful one when he is no longer afraid of you, and he is no longer afraid, because Dr. Miriam Cole sat with him while he wrote it, and I witnessed it."

Bennett reached into his coat, slowly, the way a man reaches when he wants no one to mistake a paper for a pistol, and he held up a folded sheet, and then a second thing, small and bright in the morning light, a pair of spurs, branded on the heel band with a mark that Calder recognised, and that several of Greer's riders recognised, and that Malloy recognised most of all, because they were his, and they had been found near the burned line cabin, where no foreman doing lawful business had any reason to have dropped them in the ashes. "These were found in the cabin's remains," Bennett said. "Your men said the fire was an accident. Accidents do not leave a man's spurs in a place he swore he never entered, Mr. Malloy, and they do not leave a cut fence in a straight line, and they do not leave a woman's rope on a post that was driven into ground where no post belongs."

For a moment, the boundary held its breath. The wind stopped, or seemed to stop, and the hawk cried again, far and high, and the horses stood with their heads low, as if they too were waiting for the decision that would be made by men, not by animals. Greer looked at the spurs, and then at Malloy, and then at his riders, and Calder saw, in that look, the exact moment when a man who has always been obeyed realises that obedience has a limit, and that the limit has just been reached. One rider, a younger man with dust on his boots and a face that had not yet learned to hide what it felt, turned his horse a half-step away from Greer, not a retreat, not yet, but a widening, a space. Another followed. A third looked at Naya, and then at the post, and then down at his own hands, and Calder saw shame there, plain and unadorned, and he knew that shame, handled rightly, could be the beginning of something better than fear.

Malloy, Bennett said, and his voice was level, and final. "You are under arrest, again, and this time you will ride to Copper Bend with my deputies, and you will stay there until a judge hears you. Assault. Arson. False report. And now, riding armed onto a man's land to intimidate a witness. You can ride quietly, or you can ride in irons. Your choice, and it is the last easy choice you will get today."

Malloy looked at Greer, as if Greer might yet save him, as if the man who had sent him to do these things might now stand between him and the law, and Greer looked back at him and said nothing, and in that silence, Malloy understood what Calder had understood long ago, that men like Greer used other men the way they used fences, to mark what was theirs, and discarded them when the fence fell. Malloy's shoulders sagged, not in surrender exactly, but in the recognition that the story he had told himself, about loyalty and business and a hard country that required hard deeds, had run out of ground to stand on. He swung down from his horse, slowly, and held out his hands, and a deputy stepped forward and took them, and the sound of the irons, when they closed, was small and metallic and, in the vast morning, strangely final.

News in the same category

Do Whatever You Want,” the Cowboy Said — But the Apache Woman’s Next Words Changed Everything

45 Part