Do Whatever You Want,” the Cowboy Said — But the Apache Woman’s Next Words Changed Everything

Chapter 32

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

That was when Deke Malloy came in from the front room, where he had been waiting with his hat in his hands and his temper already rising.

This is a mistake, Sheriff, Malloy said, and his voice was too loud for the hour. "That woman stole a Greer horse. I saw the brand myself. You can't just turn her loose because a rancher and a doctor tell a story."

Bennett did not rise. He pointed at the spurs.

Then explain those, Deke, he said. "They were found at the line cabin after the fire. Your men left them when they ran. One of your riders had them on when he tied a woman to a post. That's not horse theft. That's assault."

Malloy's face reddened. He opened his mouth, closed it, and then tried another tack, louder still.

Greer owns the water in that valley, he said. "That band has no right to the spring, and Vann has no right to harbour them. This whole thing is about water, and everybody in Copper Bend knows it."

Then Greer can say so himself, Bennett said.

As if summoned by the name, Harlan Greer entered from the street, his coat brushed, his boots polished, his expression arranged into the calm of a man who believed money could still smooth a morning. He looked at Naya, and then at the spurs, and then at Bennett, and he smiled the thin smile of a man accustomed to being believed.

Sheriff, this is a misunderstanding that has grown legs, Greer said. "My foreman acted to protect company property. If a woman was hurt, I regret it, but I did not order any such thing. I deny it, plainly and entirely."

Before Bennett could answer, the door at the back of the jailhouse opened, and Henry Doyle came in. The storekeeper looked as if he had not slept either. His apron was twisted in his hands, his eyes were on the floor, and when he spoke, his voice was small in a way that made the room go still.

Sheriff, Doyle said, "I have to say it, or I won't be able to look at myself in my own store again. Mr. Greer pressed me. He came to my counter and he asked, day after day, where Naya went, and when she went, and who she was with. He said it was about a horse. I believed him at first, and then I didn't, and I kept telling him anyway because I was afraid of losing his trade. I told him about the ride to the spring. I told him about the morning she went to Dr. Cole's. I am ashamed of it, and I am saying it here, in front of you, because it is true."

The silence after Doyle's words was different from the silence before them. It was not the silence of a jailhouse at dawn. It was the silence of a story changing shape in front of witnesses.

Greer's smile thinned to nothing.

Henry, he said, "you are tired. You don't know what you're saying."

I know exactly what I'm saying, Doyle said, and he lifted his eyes at last, not to Greer, but to Naya. "I'm sorry, miss. I was wrong. I won't be pressed again."

Bennett wrote Doyle's name in his book, and the scratch of the pen was the only sound in the room for a long moment. Then he stood, and he looked at each man in turn, and his voice carried the weight of the office he held.

Miss Naya, he said, "you are free to go, and you are free to stay, and no man in this town will lay a hand on you again while I wear this badge. Calder, Seth, take her home. Doctor, thank you. Mr. Doyle, you will come back tomorrow and sign what you just said. Mr. Malloy, Mr. Greer, you will stay in Copper Bend. We are not finished here. Not by a long way."

Outside, the sun had cleared the roofs, and the street was beginning to wake. Naya stepped into the light, and Calder walked beside her, not ahead of her and not behind her, and Seth fell in on her other side. The air smelled of dust and fresh bread from the bakery, and for the first time since the post, Naya breathed it in as a woman who had spoken and been heard, and who would not be made small again by any man's claim.

The hearing was held two days later in the Copper Bend courthouse, a plain room with whitewashed walls, a high ceiling, and windows that let in the heat even with the shutters half closed. The benches were filled before Bennett called the room to order: ranchers from the valley, townspeople from Copper Bend, storekeepers, a few of Greer's riders standing at the back with their hats in their hands and their eyes down, and Frank O'Dell, Calder's neighbour, sitting in the front row with his cane across his knees, as if he had come to make sure no one forgot that he had seen the fence cut with his own eyes.

Calder sat beside Naya, and Seth sat on her other side, and the arrangement was deliberate. She was not flanked by protectors. She was seated between two men who knew her story and would not speak over her. Dr. Miriam Cole sat behind them, her bag at her feet, her hands folded, her face calm. Henry Doyle sat further back, alone, his shoulders hunched, as if he were already bracing himself for the part where he would have to say his shame aloud a second time.

News in the same category

Do Whatever You Want,” the Cowboy Said — But the Apache Woman’s Next Words Changed Everything

45 Part