"Your side: a warranty deed from the Lindqvist estate, recorded. Cash purchase, no lender, no ambiguity. A title policy issued on that deed. A survey showing your parcel outside the Braddock Shores plat. Tax records in your name. Possession — you live there. That is as clean a position as a property owner gets in this state."
"And her side?"
"On the record I can search from this office — nothing. I ran it twice before you got here. There is no recorded annexation of your parcel. No covenant running with your land in favor of Braddock Shores. No membership agreement with your name, or Walter Lindqvist's, that shows up in the normal chain. If Evelyn Harrow walked into court this afternoon with what she's sent you, a judge would ask her what she's talking about, in politer words."
Something in my shoulders let go. "Then we're done?"
"No." He tapped the other side of his line, where he had written one word and circled it. INDEX. "We're almost done, which in title work is a different country. When I ran the grantor-grantee index for Lindqvist — the name index, going back further than a standard search goes — there's an entry. One entry. It references an instrument affecting the east-shore parcels, indexed in a way I haven't seen before, and when I tried to pull the instrument itself through the usual channel, it didn't resolve. The reference is there. The document, through normal searching, effectively isn't."
"What does that mean?"
"It might mean a mis-indexed nothing. Old counties are full of them — a clerk in 1998 types a parcel number wrong and creates a ghost that lives in the index for thirty years. It might mean an instrument recorded in a batch and never properly cross-referenced. What it does not mean—" he held up a hand, because he could see me doing arithmetic with my face "—is that it changes your title today. Your title is yours. But I don't like ghosts, Marcus. Especially ghosts that appear in the same summer a homeowners' association invents an emergency."
He turned to a fresh page and started a list, out loud, as he wrote. The title company's complete file — not the policy jacket from closing, the whole file: the commitment, the search notes, the examiner's worksheet, every instrument the examiner had pulled and every one they'd noted and set aside. The full recorded chain for my parcel back to 1968, when Walter built the cabin, and for the two parcels on either side. The Braddock Shores plat and every amendment. The association's corporate filings with the state.
"You sound like you're building something," I said.
"I am. I'm building the version of this that a judge reads in twenty minutes." He capped his pen. "Let me work the paper for two weeks before you do anything new. No new replies to her except 'Received, referred to counsel,' with the date. If she sends a man, a crew, a process server, a saint — you call me and you call Baines, in that order if it's polite, in the other order if it isn't. Can you live with that?"
"That's how I've been living with it," I said. "Only without the counsel part."
Driving home, I thought about method. An engineer doesn't start with the conclusion that a bridge is failing. He starts with the loads. He writes down every force actually on the structure — dead load, live load, wind, the weight of the thing itself standing there year after year — and sets aside every force that is only rumored. Then he checks the members one at a time.
That night, at the kitchen table, I started a new section at the back of the box. Not letters. A log. Columns, because columns are honest. Date. Item. Source. Verified or not. I put the deed in the verified column, and the survey, and the tax records, and Baines standing on my dock saying "He's the owner" to a woman with a clipboard.
In the unverified column, in pencil, I wrote only one word, and circled it the way Reyes had.
Index.
They came on a Tuesday in August, in a white pickup with no markings on the doors, and if I hadn't been on the porch with coffee I would have missed the first five minutes, which I suspect was the plan.
There were three of them. Two younger men with a total station and a bundle of stakes, and an older man with a tablet who did the pointing. They didn't come up my drive. They came in from the north, along the tree line where Frank's property and mine meet in a way that looks like no property at all. Frank was in Marquette visiting his sister. I think they knew that too.
By the time I got down there, phone in hand, they had the tripod set up on my land, forty feet inside my north line, and the younger men were walking a line toward the dock with a measuring wheel.
"Morning," I said. "You're on private property."
The man with the tablet didn't look up for a moment, which was a performance, and then he did. "We're doing survey work for the shoreline project."
"Which project? Whose survey? Do you have authorization to be on this parcel?"
"We're contracted," he said. "You'd have to talk to the association office."
"I'm talking to you. Show me a credential, a work order, a plat — anything with this address on it."
He held up the tablet as if the tablet itself were a credential. The screen showed a map with no parcel numbers I could read from six feet away. "Sir, we're just taking measurements. We'll be done in an hour."