FULL STORY: HOA Karen Stormed My Lake Cabin With Police—She Went Silent When the State Attorney General Stood Up

Chapter 14

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"I didn't vote for any letter that went to you," she said. "Saying that costs me something at a board table I'm still sitting at, so I'd be grateful if you'd hear the rest before you decide what I am."

"I'm listening on a dock," I said. "It's where I do my best listening. Ask Sergeant Baines."

That got a real smile, brief and tired. "Paul Baines. Yes. That call was discussed, after. Not the way you'd hope." She looked across the water toward the clubhouse. "Marcus, the board has been told — for years, since before I joined it — that the east shore was already settled years ago. The annexation was done in the nineties, the owners consented, the paperwork was with the county. When your letters started, Evelyn presented them as administration: a holdout parcel being brought into compliance with something decided in 1998. I believed—" She stopped and corrected herself, a teacher's habit. "I repeated it. In June I told my neighbors your ownership had been resolved years ago and the association was being patient. I am sorry for that specifically."

"June," I said, "there was no annexation. I've got a recorded deed, a title policy, and an attorney in Traverse City who went looking for an annexation the way you'd look for a gas leak, and found a smell and no source. What there is, as of this month, is a lien on my parcel for assessments since 1998, standing on a consent my seller supposedly signed in 1997. Walter Lindqvist, who is dead."

She was quiet. "I didn't know about a lien."

"I thought you might not."

"Liens were discussed in the abstract, the way boards discuss paint colors. I don't recall a vote. Priya takes the minutes; Priya would know. Priya Nair, our secretary — she writes down everything." June put her hands in her pockets. "As a person, not as a board: do you intend to sell? Half the west shore thinks this ends with you selling in the fall. Evelyn has implied the association might facilitate a purchase if things became untenable for you."

It was the first honest sentence anyone from across the lake had said to me, and it deserved one back.

"I bought that cabin with savings from twenty years of bridges, four years after my wife died, because it was quiet and it was mine. I am not selling in the fall, or facilitating anything. I'm going to keep it, and sit on that porch. That's the whole plan."

"It is a good plan," she said quietly. Then, like a woman setting a fragile fact on the table: "The reserves are tight. That's the word Evelyn uses — tight. The clubhouse roof was done twice in five years, I've never had a straight answer about the dredging, and when I ask Gerald about the numbers, Gerald looks at the ceiling. Gerald Fenn, our treasurer. He has been looking at ceilings for two years."

"Is that why the east shore matters so much? A marina, June? Land?"

I had guessed, and I watched the guess land. She neither confirmed nor denied it, which from a retired schoolteacher is a kind of confirmation.

"I've said more than I meant to," she said. "And less than I know. Let me ask some questions of my own, in rooms where I'm allowed to ask them. I won't carry tales back to that board table — not yours. But I won't promise you the moon either."

"I'm an engineer," I said. "I never take delivery of the moon. It never matches the drawings."

She laughed, properly, and put out her hand. Wary, both of us. But it was the first hand from across the lake offered palm-out, with nothing in it.

Reyes found Ingrid Lindqvist-Pruitt through the estate file and one phone call to a Duluth number that had been her father's before it was hers. He called me first, because she was not a witness yet — the first voice she heard about it should be the man living in her father's cabin.

"Keep it simple," he said. "Who you are, what turned up, what you'd like to ask. Don't say forgery like it's proven. Say signature like it's a question. If she hangs up, she hangs up."

She did not hang up.

I called on a Sunday evening, because Reyes said people answer then like themselves. A woman answered with the slight impatience of someone expecting a different call, and I said, "Mrs. Lindqvist-Pruitt, my name is Marcus Hale. I bought your father's cabin on Lake Braddock."

A pause. Then the impatience went out of her voice. "The cabin," she said. "How is the dock? It leaned. It leaned when I was nine."

"It still leans," I said. "Left. I've been advised to call it character."

"My father built that dock twice and it leaned both times. He said the lake wanted it that way." I could hear her sit down. "Marcus — is something wrong with the title?"

"The title from you to me is fine. I want you to hear that first. Something has been filed since — by the association across the lake. They claim that in 1997 your father signed a consent to annex his parcel into Braddock Shores, that the parcel was annexed in 1998 on the strength of it, and that assessments are owed. There's a lien on my land now because of it. My attorney has the consent. It has a signature meant to be your father's."

The line was quiet long enough that I checked the phone. Then Ingrid laughed — not Reyes's startled laugh. A short, hard, single note, like a hand coming down flat on a table.

"No," she said.

"Ingrid—"

News in the same category

FULL STORY: HOA Karen Stormed My Lake Cabin With Police—She Went Silent When the State Attorney General Stood Up

30 Part