I opened it for what I intended to be the last time as an active file. Everything was there in order: the welcome letter with its $1,200 initiation fee, the dock violation, the stain complaint, the ownership verification notice, my surveys and deeds in their copies, the photographs of stakes near my dock, the lien, the consent with its traced signature, Priya's minutes, the letter of intent, the ruling, Kovich's note. A whole structure of paper, load by load, that had once held up a claim on my life.
I put June's letter on top of all of it. The apology as the final document. The acknowledgment as the last item in.
Then I closed the box and put the quilt back over it, and went out to the porch, where the lake was doing its late-afternoon work with the light, and thought that a box can end as a history instead of a weapon. That is the best ending paper ever gets.
I repaired the dock in the spring, over the better part of a week, a few hours at a time, the way you do work you are not in a hurry to finish.
It had leaned to the left since before my time — Walter's dock, settled into the lake bottom at its own angle sometime in the decades before Braddock Shores existed. For a year I had photographed that lean, documented it, defended it in correspondence. It had been Exhibit Whatever in a dispute about jurisdiction. Now the dispute was over, and the lean was just a lean again: posts sunk unevenly, a stringer rotted at the waterline, the whole thing asking, in the plain language of structures, for attention.
Frank Ouellette came down on the second day with a level, a pry bar, and opinions.
"You can't just shim that and call it good," he said, standing on the shore in waders he had owned since approximately the Korean War. "Posts have to come up. We reset the two on the deep end."
"We?" I said.
"I supervise. It's a skilled trade, supervising." He handed me the pry bar. "Also I brought sandwiches. Supervisors bring sandwiches."
We worked the way Frank does everything, slowly and correctly, with breaks for coffee on the porch that stretched longer than the work intervals between them. We pulled the decking, jacked the frame, reset the deep posts on new footings, replaced the rotted stringer with lumber I hauled from the yard in town. My hands remembered work like that — honest loads, honest spans — from twenty years of bridges, scaled down to a dock a man could fix with a neighbor and a week.
On the fourth day, standing knee-deep in cold lake water, holding a post plumb while Frank sighted along it, I understood what I was actually doing. I was not fixing a violation. I was not maintaining property values or complying with anything. I was caring for a thing because it was mine to care for. The lean had been Walter's, and then the lawsuit's. The straightening was mine.
On the fifth day we re-laid the decking, board by board, keeping the good cedar and replacing two boards that had gone soft at the ends. I worked from the shore outward and Frank worked from the water inward, and we met, as planned, in the middle, which Frank declared a triumph of engineering coordination and I declared the only possible outcome of two men laying boards on the same dock. We screwed the last board down and then, without discussing it, both sat on the finished work with our boots in the water, testing the way you test a chair you have just built — with your full weight and your full skepticism. It held us. The level, laid across it for the last time, set its bubble dead center and stayed there.
By Saturday the dock stood level. It looked, Frank said, almost too respectable. "People will think you're association now."
"People will think a retired engineer finally got around to it," I said.
That was the weekend Tom, Ray, and Sam came back.
They arrived Friday evening with the same cooler, the same optimism, and Ray's laugh arriving half a minute before the rest of him. Tom Okafor brought a new rod he did not know how to use. Sam Whitaker brought, as he had the first time, the quiet of a man who has known me longest and needed to say least about the year in between. They had followed the case in the summarized way of friends at a distance — Sam had read the ruling, Ray had read Sam's summary of the ruling — and there was a moment, that first evening, when they stood on the new dock in a row, testing it.
"Solid," Tom said, bouncing slightly, an engineer unable not to.
"It doesn't lean," Ray said. "I liked the lean. The lean had character."
"The lean had rot," I said.
"Character rot," Ray said, and cast his line directly into the reeds, where it stayed for some time.
They fished badly. I want to be accurate about this, as I was in the photographs I once mailed to Evelyn Harrow in my own defense. Tom fished with great theoretical knowledge and caught nothing. Ray caught a boot — not his own — and held it up like a trophy. Sam caught one fish, a modest perch, looked at it with genuine respect, and let it go. I caught two and said nothing, which is the oldest rule of fishing friendship.
That night we built a fire in the stone fireplace, the first fire that fireplace had held for company since — well, since Camille, if I am honest. The cabin filled with the smell of woodsmoke and the sound of Ray losing an argument with Tom about bridge loads that Ray had started purely for entertainment. Sam sat in the chair by the window and fell asleep for ten minutes, the way old friends do in houses where they feel unguarded, and woke up denying it.