FULL STORY: HOA Karen Stormed My Lake Cabin With Police—She Went Silent When the State Attorney General Stood Up

Chapter 24

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Ms. Nair, you reviewed the association's minute books for 1997 and 1998 at my request," Reyes said. "Did the board vote to annex the east-shore parcels?"

"No," she said. "There is no such vote."

"Was there a meeting at which annexation was discussed?"

"There is no meeting in the book for the date on the resolution. The board did not meet that week. The minutes go from August to October. There is no September meeting, and no annexation in August or October, or in any other month I was able to find."

"And what were you told about the Northwood letter of intent?"

Priya glanced, once, toward the association's table. Evelyn Harrow sat there in a dark blue suit, her leather clipboard flat on the table in front of her, both hands resting on it like it was a railing.

"I was told it was a study," Priya said. "A possibility. I was not told it had been signed."

Reyes closed his folder. "Nothing further."

On cross, association counsel tried to make absence into uncertainty — missing pages, old books. Priya did not bend. "I keep the minutes," she said. "If it had been voted, it would be there. That is what minutes are for."

When court recessed, the judge did not rule. He took the matter under advisement for a written decision. But before he stood, he looked down the association's table and said, "Counsel, I advise your client to review very carefully any further filings it intends to make in this matter," and everyone understood what had collapsed.

In the corridor, Evelyn passed me without her usual smile. The clipboard was still in her hand, but her fingers were white around its edge.

"You have made a great many people unhappy, Mr. Hale," she said quietly.

"I know," I said. "I'm sorry about that part."

She looked at me as if she had expected something else — anger, triumph, anything she could answer. Then she walked on.

The ruling arrived on a Tuesday, ten days later, in an envelope too plain for what it contained.

Reyes called before the copy reached me. "Read it when it comes," he said. "But you can go home, Marcus. I mean in the legal sense. You already were home in every other sense."

The judge's language was dry, and I read it three times at my kitchen table because dry language, when it is exact, can be more moving than any other kind.

Title was quieted in Marcus Hale. Solely, exclusively, in fee simple, as it had been since the day my deed was recorded.

The annexation resolution purportedly adopted in 1998 was declared void. The consent to annexation bearing Walter Lindqvist's name was declared void, and the court found, in plain words I had not expected a court to use, that the signature was forged and the document had not been executed by Walter Lindqvist.

The association's lien against my parcel, for assessments dating from an annexation that had never lawfully occurred, was discharged in full and ordered expunged.

Braddock Shores Association, its officers and agents, were enjoined — permanently — from asserting any claim of ownership, membership, or jurisdiction over my parcel, from entering the parcel except as any member of the public lawfully might, and from filing any further instrument against it without leave of court.

Damages were awarded for the cloud on my title and the costs the association's actions had imposed, and my attorney fees were awarded in full, because, the judge wrote, the association had not merely been mistaken. It had persisted after it had reason to know.

And on the last page, in a short paragraph, the court referred the matter of the forged consent to the county prosecutor for investigation.

I sat with that paragraph for a while. I had wanted it. I had wanted someone with authority to say the word forged somewhere it would matter. Now that it was said, I felt no lift from it — only a kind of tiredness, the way you feel after carrying a load a long distance and setting it down correctly, on its footings, at last.

Reyes came by that weekend with a bottle of something decent and the final papers for my archive box. We went through them the way we had gone through everything, page by page.

"The injunction is the part that protects you going forward," he said. "The voiding is the part that fixes the past. You needed both."

"What happens with the prosecutor?" I asked.

"That is no longer yours to carry. There will be an investigation. It will take the time it takes. My advice is to answer if they call, and otherwise let it move at its own pace."

"And the association can appeal."

"They can," he said. "They won't get far, and their own members know what's in the record now. But if they do, we answer. Don't spend the winter waiting for a letter, Marcus. That would be letting them keep something the court just gave back to you."

On Monday I drove a certified copy of the judgment to Marlene Kovich's office myself. I could have let Reyes file it, and he offered, but some errands you run in person. Kovich's clerk stamped it, recorded it in sequence — that phrase again, now working in my favor — and handed me the receipt across the counter. It was a small piece of paper for the end of a year of large ones. I put it in my wallet for the drive home, the way a man carries a ferry ticket until he is safely across, and only when I was back at the cabin did I file it where it belonged, behind the ruling, in the box.

News in the same category

FULL STORY: HOA Karen Stormed My Lake Cabin With Police—She Went Silent When the State Attorney General Stood Up

30 Part