Wade looked at her, and at the shack, and at the corral where Roach stood watching them both, and he thought that being nursed back by the woman he had chosen, and who had chosen him, was a different thing from being saved by a decree. It was better. It was his, and hers, and no one else's.
The council met at the well, because the well was the thing they were all, in the end, trying to protect, and because neutral ground was easier to stand on when every man present had reason to be wary.
Wade had proposed it, and he had ridden out himself to carry the invitations: to Chief Stone Wolf at the camp, to Sheriff Dan O'Rourke in San Tomas, to Foreman Hays at the B-Bar. He had expected refusals, or at least delays. Instead each man had agreed at once, as if all of them had been waiting for someone to say the thing out loud.
They came in the morning, when the light was still kind. Stone Wolf came with Kasen and two older men of the council, riding without rifles slung across their backs — a gesture Wade did not miss, and one he knew had cost the old chief something to make, because a chief who rides unarmed into a meeting with a sheriff is trusting more than his own safety. O'Rourke came alone, his badge bright, his face tired, riding a horse that had seen better days and a man who had seen worse. Hays came with a young hand who carried a ledger, because Hays believed, correctly, that paper outlasted memory, and because a foreman who brings numbers to a council is a foreman who intends to be believed.
Wade had set out chairs and a bench under the windmill, and Nita had put out coffee and bread, and for a moment the whole thing looked almost ordinary: four parties to a dispute, sitting in the shade, drinking coffee. Nita poured for each man herself, and Wade noticed that she poured for her father last, and that Stone Wolf accepted the cup with a small nod, as if acknowledging that his daughter had become, in this house, a host in her own right and not merely a chief's daughter on display. Then Stone Wolf spoke, and the ordinary fell away.
My people did not steal Barlow's horses, he said. "We have said this, and now the tracks have said it, and still the town says it. I am tired of defending my people against a story told by the man who profits from it."
O'Rourke nodded, and Wade saw the weariness in him too — the weariness of a sheriff caught between a town that wanted a simple villain and evidence that refused to supply one.
I have ridden the canyon trail myself since the posse day, O'Rourke said. "The tracks run to the dry canyon. The horses were led by men in boots. And there is a pattern here I should have named sooner. Every theft has come just before a drive, when the herds are moving and a few head missing are hard to count. Every theft has been blamed on the band. And every time, the band has been the only party with nothing to gain and everything to lose."
One of the older council men spoke then, his voice rough with years and with distrust. "We have heard town law promise before," he said. "And town law has ridden into our camp with rifles more often than it has ridden in with coffee. Why should we trust this watch?"
It was Stone Wolf who answered, and his answer was the measure of the man. "Because this time the law sits at our water, and the man who owns the water sits with us, and the man who counts the horses has brought his book. Trust is not given because it is asked. It is given because it is watched, day by day, until it holds. We will watch it together, and if it fails, we will know whose hand failed it."
Hays opened his ledger and laid it on his knee. "Barlow has lost eleven head in four months," he said. "I have the brands and the dates. And I have something else. One of the stolen horses was found last week in a herd Grady was driving to the railhead, with a fresh brand burned over the old one. The brand underneath was ours. I have the hide man who saw it, and he will swear to it."
Wade felt the pieces click together the way fence wire clicks when it is finally taut. This was what the council was for — not speeches, but the laying out of facts where all could see them, so that no one man could carry the story alone anymore.
Grady's pattern is this, Wade said, and he spoke slowly, because he wanted every word to land. "He steals Barlow horses and others'. He blames the band, so the town looks at the camp instead of at him. He waters his stolen herds where he thinks no one watches — and he wants my well, because it is the only sweet water between here and the railhead that a man can reach without being seen from the road. He framed Kasen because Kasen was tracking him. He had my shack ransacked because he wanted whatever paper would tell him where the camp is and when I am gone. And he had me shot on the San Tomas trail because I would not look away."
He stopped, and the windmill creaked above them, and the trough water moved in the wind.
Stone Wolf looked at O'Rourke. "What do you propose, Sheriff?"