The sheriff's office in San Tomas smelled of coal smoke and old paper, and the morning light coming through the single window fell in a hard yellow bar across the desk where Fenn sat with his hands tied in front of him. He was not a big man. Wade had thought him bigger in the dark at the well, when the shouting and the rifle fire had made everything larger than it was. In daylight he was thin, sunburned, with a cut on his cheek where he had fallen, and his eyes kept moving to the door as if he expected Grady to walk through it and settle the matter himself.
Sheriff Dan O'Rourke did not raise his voice. That was his way, and Wade had learned to respect it. The sheriff set a tin cup of water in front of Fenn and sat down across from him, and for a long while nobody said anything at all. The clock ticked. Somewhere outside, a wagon went by with a load of lumber, and the sound of it faded down the street.
You know what you're facing, O'Rourke said at last. "Horse theft is a hanging matter in some counties. This one has a jail instead, but the jail is not a kind place, and the judge is not a kind man."
Fenn looked at the water and did not drink.
Grady left you, O'Rourke said. "He left you at the well with the horses and rode off while you were still shouting. A man who will leave you is a man you owe nothing."
That got through. Wade saw it in the way Fenn's jaw worked, the way his hands tightened on each other until the knuckles went white.
He said the well was ours for the taking, Fenn said, and his voice came out rough, as if he had not used it since the night before. "He said the gentler would run. He said the Apache would take the blame."
Tell me about the brands, O'Rourke said.
Fenn told him. He told him in the slow, flat way of a man who has decided that the truth is the only thing left that might buy him anything. Grady had been running stolen horses through the border country for two years, changing brands with a running iron, selling them to buyers who asked no questions. The horses from Barlow's herds were the best of it — big, sound animals that brought good money — and the Apache had been useful to him twice over, first as a screen and then as a scapegoat, because a town frightened of Indians did not look closely at a white man with a bill of sale.
Where's the ledger? O'Rourke asked.
Fenn hesitated, and Wade understood the hesitation. The ledger was the one thing that could hang Grady instead of Fenn, and a man does not give up his last piece of trade without weighing it.
In the line shack, Fenn said finally. "South fork of the dry creek. Under the floorboard by the stove. He keeps the sales in it. Names, prices, brands as they were and brands as he made them."
O'Rourke wrote it down. He wrote slowly, in a careful hand, and when he had finished he looked at Wade.
You'll ride with me to fetch it, he said. It was not quite a question.
Wade nodded. He had expected it, and he had already decided. The thing had to be finished properly, with paper and proof, or it would come back on them all like a wind that had only gone around the hill.
They rode out before noon, Wade and the sheriff and two deputies, with Kasen riding a little ahead as scout. Nita had wanted to come, and Wade had told her to stay at the claim and watch the well, and she had looked at him in the way she had when she was deciding whether to argue, and then she had nodded once and gone to saddle her own horse anyway — not to follow, she said, but to ride the north trail and make sure no one came at the claim from behind while the men were gone. Wade did not argue further. He had learned, by then, when argument was useful and when it was only noise.
The line shack stood where Fenn had said, low and weather-beaten, with a roof that sagged in the middle. Inside it smelled of mice and old grease. The floorboard by the stove came up with a pry of the sheriff's knife, and under it lay a leather-bound book, swollen with damp at the corners, its pages filled with Grady's hand — a cramped, slanting hand that got worse when the sums got bigger.
Wade stood over O'Rourke's shoulder and read what he could. There were the Barlow horses, listed by their true brands and then again by the brands Grady had burned over them. There were buyers' names in towns Wade had never been to. There were dates that matched the thefts, and sums that made Wade's throat tighten — more money than he had ever seen in one place, made out of other men's horses and other men's blame.
That's him, O'Rourke said quietly. "That's the whole of him, right there in ink."