I know, she said. "That is why I married you — no, that is why I stayed. Not because my father decreed it. Because you are the man who goes to the bleeding thing first."
Wade did not answer at once. He rode on, listening to the gravel and the wind, and he thought that if there was a better thing a wife could say to a husband, he had never heard it.
The hearing was held in San Tomas three weeks later, in the courthouse that doubled as the town hall, a plain room with whitewashed walls and benches that had been carried in from the church for the occasion. Wade had never sat in a courtroom before, and he found it stranger than he had expected — not grand, the way he had imagined from his mother's books, but ordinary, with a stove ticking in the corner and a clerk who kept sharpening his pencil, and the whole town crowded in to hear what would be said about horses and brands and a man who had blamed his neighbors for his own crimes.
Grady sat at the defense table with his shoulder still bandaged under his shirt, his face thinner than it had been at the arroyo, his hands quiet in front of him. Moss sat beside him, smaller still, and Fenn sat apart, under guard, waiting to be called. Wade sat with Nita on one side of him and Kasen on the other, and behind them Foreman Hays and a dozen Barlow men, and behind them townspeople Wade knew by sight and some he had never seen before. Chief Stone Wolf had come as well, and sat with the dignity of a man attending to business that was his own, because the band's name had been dragged through this matter and the clearing of it belonged to him as much as to anyone.
The judge was a circuit judge, a gray man with a voice that carried without effort, and he ran the hearing the way a good foreman runs a roundup — no wasted motion, no raised voice, everything in its order. Sheriff O'Rourke spoke first, laying out the thefts, the altered brands, the ledger found under the floorboard of the line shack, the buyers' names in Grady's own hand. He spoke plainly, and the room listened in the particular silence of people hearing a thing they had suspected and had not wanted to believe.
Then Fenn was called, and he told his story again, the way he had told it in the sheriff's office, only now with the whole town listening. He did not spare himself. He said Grady had planned the thefts and the blame together, that the Apache were useful because a frightened town looks everywhere except at its own. He said the ledger was Grady's, kept by Grady's hand. When the defense lawyer asked him whether he was only saying these things to save his own skin, Fenn looked at the floor and said, "I'm saying them because they're true, and because I was there."
Wade was called next. He told the court about the well, and the trap, and the night at the arroyo, and about going to Grady first when he was bleeding, because a man bleeding is a man bleeding, whatever else he is. He told it simply, without dressing it up, and he was aware of Nita's hand on his arm when he sat down again, steadying him the way she steadied a nervous horse — not by force, but by being there.
Kasen spoke after him, and the room went very still, because an Apache warrior giving testimony in a San Tomas courtroom was not a thing anyone present had seen before. Kasen spoke in clear, careful English, and he told how he had been shot while tracking stolen horses, how Wade had carried him to the shack and hidden him and tended him, how the band had been blamed for thefts they had not committed while their own horses were being taken too. He did not raise his voice. He did not need to. The facts, laid out plainly, did the work.
Foreman Hays identified his horses, brand by brand, and the ledger was passed around the bench, and the judge examined it for a long time, turning pages with a slow finger, while the room waited. When he finally looked up, his face gave nothing away, but his voice was firm.
Walt Grady, he said, "on the evidence of the ledger, the testimony of three witnesses, and the recovered horses bearing altered brands, this court finds you guilty of horse theft, of fraud, and of conspiracy to defame. You are sentenced to ten years in the territorial prison. Your men will be sentenced separately, with their cooperation taken into account."
There was a sound then, not quite a cheer, more like a long breath let out by a whole room at once. The judge went on, in the same firm voice, to sentence the other two men. Fenn, for his cooperation and his honest testimony, received three years — a hard sentence, but not a hopeless one, and Wade saw Fenn close his eyes as if a weight he had carried for months had shifted rather than lifted. Moss, who had followed and had not led, received five. Wade thought about the arithmetic of it — ten, five, three — and about how the law measured guilt the way a man measures lumber, in lengths, when the real measure was always something else: the horses returned, the name cleared, the valley able to look at itself again without flinching.