Those were the words he repeated whenever sleep abandoned him.
Yet every repetition made them sound smaller.
Because he had been there.
He had watched.
And when the first screams rose from the settlement, he had done nothing.
A sharp gust of wind swept across the trail.
Caleb blinked, returning to the present.
Rust was struggling through a drift that reached almost to his chest.
"Come on," Caleb whispered. "Just a little farther."
The horse lowered his head and pushed forward.
They reached a narrow shelf of exposed rock where the snow had blown away. Caleb allowed Rust to rest while he examined the country ahead.
The trail disappeared between two steep walls of granite before turning into a forested basin.
Beyond that lay a pass he hoped to cross before another storm arrived.
He took a small brass compass from his coat pocket.
Its glass was cracked.
The needle trembled before settling north.
Caleb studied it briefly, then returned it to his pocket.
Beside the compass lay a folded letter he had carried for nearly six months.
The paper had softened along its creases, and the ink had begun to fade where rain had once soaked through his coat.
He knew every word.
Caleb,
I have heard things about Harlan that you ought to know.
There are men who remember what happened in the basin, and not all of them intend to remain silent.
If you still possess the courage to face that morning, come north.
Ask for Elias Ward.
He will know where to find me.
There had been no signature.
Only a small mark beneath the final sentence: three intersecting lines drawn in black ink.
Caleb had spent months trying to decide whether the letter represented an opportunity, a trap, or merely another cruelty devised by someone who knew his past.
He still had not decided.
But he had ridden north.
That much, at least, was true.
Rust suddenly stopped.
Not the gradual hesitation of a tired horse confronting difficult ground.
He stopped so abruptly that Caleb shifted forward in the saddle.
The gelding's ears stood rigid.
His nostrils widened.
Every muscle beneath the saddle tightened.
Caleb's hand moved toward the Winchester.
"What is it, boy?"
Rust stared into the forest.
Caleb followed his gaze.
Nothing moved among the trees.
Snow covered the ground in an unbroken white sheet. The pines stood motionless beneath their heavy crowns, and the gray cliffs beyond them rose like walls surrounding an abandoned fortress.
Then he heard it.
A metallic clank.
Sharp.
Heavy.
Utterly unnatural.
The sound came from somewhere beyond the trees, perhaps a quarter mile away.
Caleb remained still.
A moment passed.
Then another.
He heard a low groan.
Human.
There was no mistaking it.
His fingers tightened around the rifle.
A second metallic crack rang through the forest, followed by the scraping sound of iron dragged violently against stone.
Then silence.
Caleb looked toward the narrow pass ahead.
He could continue riding.
Whatever had happened in the forest was none of his concern.
Men died in the mountains every winter. Some froze after losing the trail. Some fell from ledges hidden beneath snow. Others encountered wolves, thieves, or desperate men willing to kill for a horse and a warm coat.
He had survived as long as he had by refusing to become involved in the troubles of strangers.
Rust shifted uneasily.
Caleb touched the gelding's neck.
"Not our business," he said.
The words sounded reasonable.
He turned the horse slightly toward the pass.
Then the scream came.
It rose from deep among the pines, raw and terrible, and struck the canyon walls with such force that the echoes seemed to multiply it.
Caleb felt his stomach tighten.
For one impossible instant, he was back in Tonto Basin.
The smell of burning wood filled his nostrils.
A child was crying.
Someone was shouting for the shooting to stop.
And he was sitting motionless upon his horse.
Again.
Caleb shut his eyes.
"Damn it."
He turned Rust toward the forest.
The gelding resisted for a moment, then obeyed.
They left the trail and descended into the shadowed trees.
The snow deepened beneath the canopy, forcing Rust to lift his legs high with every step. Caleb leaned forward, searching the ground for broken branches, disturbed drifts, or signs of another horse.
The forest seemed unnaturally quiet.
Even the wind had weakened.
After several hundred yards, he noticed a dark stain upon the snow.
He reined Rust to a halt.
Blood.
Three crimson drops lay beneath a low pine branch.
A few feet farther on, the snow had been churned into a muddy depression.
Something heavy had struggled there.
Caleb dismounted.
His boots sank into the powder, and the cold immediately began working through the leather.
He examined the ground.
There were no horse tracks.
Only the marks of a man's boots, a long furrow dragged through the snow, and scattered drops of blood that grew heavier toward the trees.
The injured man had been moving away from the trail.
Or trying to.
Caleb glanced behind him.
No one followed.
He drew his Colt and checked the surrounding forest.
"Stay," he told Rust.