Then he noticed movement near the house.
Three riders stood beside the fence.
One wore a dark military coat.
Another held a rifle.
The third had dismounted and was speaking to a woman standing upon the porch.
Caleb raised the field glasses.
The woman was tall and gray-haired, wrapped in a heavy shawl.
She stood straight despite the armed men surrounding her.
Sarah Whitcomb.
Caleb focused upon the man speaking to her.
His stomach tightened.
The rider had a pale scar running from cheek to jaw.
Silas Vane.
The man Caleb had spared in the forest.
Vane leaned toward Sarah.
Even from the distant cliff, Caleb could see the threat in his posture.
Then the gunman seized the old woman by the arm.
Daniel swore.
Eleanor covered her mouth.
Nantan watched from the tunnel entrance, his face twisted with pain.
Caleb lowered the glasses.
For several seconds, he said nothing.
Then he checked the ammunition in his Winchester.
Eleanor looked at him.
"What are you going to do?"
Caleb studied the house.
The riders.
The open valley.
The long stretch of snow between them and the only person who might save Nantan's life.
He thought of Rust running alone through the forest.
Of Harlan's forged report.
Of Eleanor's confession.
And of the old woman standing unarmed before three men with rifles.
Then he answered quietly.
"Something I should've learned to do three years ago."
Eleanor stared.
"What?"
Caleb chambered a round.
"Stop them before they start killing."
The valley lay beneath the afternoon sun like a graveyard dressed for Sunday.
Snow covered the roofs of abandoned cabins, softened the collapsed timbers of the old ore shed, and concealed the ruts of a mining road that had once carried wagons loaded with silver-bearing rock. Beyond the settlement, Blackwater Creek wound between frozen banks, its dark current visible through irregular openings in the ice.
At the northern end of the valley stood Sarah Whitcomb's house.
It was a modest two-story building constructed from squared pine logs, with a steep roof, a stone chimney, and a narrow porch facing the creek. A barn stood behind it, partly sheltered by a grove of cottonwoods.
Smoke rose steadily from the chimney.
Someone had been keeping the fire alive.
Caleb watched the house through his field glasses.
Silas Vane stood on the porch, one hand gripping Sarah Whitcomb's upper arm. The old woman faced him without flinching. Her gray hair had escaped its pins, and the wind whipped loose strands across her weathered face.
Two armed men waited near the fence.
A fourth figure appeared briefly inside the house.
Caleb lowered the glasses.
"Four," he murmured.
Eleanor stood beside him.
"I only saw three."
"There's another inside."
Daniel shifted his wounded arm.
"Maybe more."
"Maybe."
Caleb looked toward the valley floor.
The distance from the mine entrance to the house was nearly half a mile. Between them stretched open ground broken by scattered boulders, collapsed buildings, and a narrow stand of pines.
Approaching directly would be suicide.
He turned toward Nantan.
The warrior sat against the tunnel wall, wrapped in blankets. His face had grown increasingly pale during their journey, and his breathing was shallow.
"Can you stay awake?"
Nantan opened his eyes.
"For what?"
"Long enough to tell me whether Sarah has another way into her house."
The warrior considered.
"Cellar."
Caleb leaned closer.
"Where?"
"Behind the kitchen. Door opens toward creek."
Eleanor nodded.
"I remember it."
"Can we reach it unseen?"
"From the cottonwoods, perhaps."
Caleb studied the terrain again.
The creek curved behind the house, passing through a shallow depression concealed by thick brush.
If they descended the western slope and followed the frozen water north, they might reach the cottonwoods without crossing the open valley.
But Nantan could barely move.
Caleb looked at Daniel.
"You're staying here with him."
The young man's expression hardened.
"I can fight."
"With one arm?"
"I can still shoot."
Caleb glanced at the bloodstained sleeve.
"Maybe. But Nantan needs someone who can keep him warm and stop him from trying to stand."
Nantan opened one eye.
"I do not need a boy watching me."
Daniel bristled.
"I'm not a boy."
The warrior studied him.
"Then stop sounding like one."
Despite the danger, Eleanor gave a faint smile.
Daniel looked offended, but he said nothing.
Caleb crouched beside the young man.
"Listen carefully. If we're not back before dark, you take Nantan into the tunnel. Stay hidden. Don't light a fire."
Daniel's expression changed.
"And if you don't come back at all?"
Caleb hesitated.
He had learned that promises were dangerous things.
Especially promises made before gunfire.
"Then you do whatever keeps him alive."
The young man swallowed.
Caleb placed a spare revolver beside him.
"Six cartridges. Don't waste them."
Daniel nodded.
Eleanor tightened her scarf.
"I'm coming with you."
Caleb looked at her.
"No."
"Sarah knows me."
"Vane knows you too."
"Exactly. If he sees me, he may hesitate."
Caleb gave her a hard look.
"Men like Vane don't hesitate. They calculate."
Eleanor's eyes narrowed.
"Then perhaps I can give him something to calculate."
Caleb studied her.