"Jonathan knew the truth about your birth. He married Elizabeth afterward and gave you his name. For a time, she hoped he would become a decent husband and father."
Caleb remembered his childhood.
The long silences at supper.
The sudden anger.
His mother's careful efforts to keep peace inside the house.
"She was wrong," he said.
Sarah nodded.
"Yes."
He looked at the locket.
"Why did she stay?"
"Because she believed leaving would put you in danger."
Caleb laughed bitterly.
"So she stayed with a man she feared."
"She stayed until she found a way to leave without him knowing where you were."
Caleb went still.
Sarah looked toward the floor.
"But Jonathan discovered her plans."
The room fell silent.
Caleb felt his heart beating.
"What happened?"
Sarah closed her eyes.
"She disappeared soon afterward."
He stared.
"And he told me she died."
"Yes."
Caleb looked down at his hands.
For twelve years, he had grieved for his mother.
For twelve years, he had carried anger toward a dead woman who had left him alone with a father he could never please.
Now he wondered whether she had spent those same years searching for a way back to him.
The thought was almost unbearable.
He turned toward Sarah.
"Do you know where she went?"
The old woman hesitated.
"Not for certain."
Caleb felt anger rise.
"Then what do you know?"
Sarah stood slowly.
"I know she was alive six years ago."
The words struck him.
Caleb stared.
"Six years?"
Sarah nodded.
"She sent me a letter."
"Where from?"
"New Mexico."
Caleb stepped toward her.
"Do you still have it?"
Sarah looked toward the stairs.
"Yes."
"Then get it."
She studied his face.
"Caleb, there are things in that letter—"
"Please."
The word escaped him before he could stop it.
Sarah's expression softened.
She nodded.
"Wait here."
She left the kitchen.
Caleb stood beside the table, staring at the staircase.
Eleanor watched him.
For several seconds, neither spoke.
Then she said quietly, "I'm sorry."
Caleb looked at her.
"For what?"
"For all of it."
He gave a tired laugh.
"That's a long list."
She lowered her eyes.
"I know."
Caleb studied her.
He wanted to ask how much she had known before sending the letter.
Whether she had deliberately drawn him into the mountains because of his connection to Thomas Redbird.
Whether she had hoped his guilt would make him useful.
But before he could speak, a heavy thud came from the pantry.
Then a scraping sound.
Caleb turned.
Vane had been quiet for several minutes.
Too quiet.
He approached the door.
"Vane?"
No answer.
Caleb drew his revolver.
"Don't make me come in there."
Silence.
He looked toward Eleanor.
She rose.
Caleb lifted the latch and opened the pantry door.
Vane sat tied to a wooden chair.
His face was swollen from the blow Caleb had given him, and angry red burns marked his cheek and neck.
But his eyes were bright.
Too bright.
Caleb immediately noticed the broken glass upon the floor.
A shattered jar.
A length of rope lay near Vane's boot.
One of the knots around his wrists had loosened.
Caleb raised the revolver.
"Hands where I can see them."
Vane smiled.
"Always suspicious."
Caleb stepped closer.
"Turn around."
The gunman obeyed slowly.
Caleb saw that Vane had been working the rope against a jagged piece of glass.
Another few minutes, and he might have freed himself.
Caleb tightened the bindings.
Vane winced.
"Careful. You're hurting me."
"That would be a shame."
The gunman laughed softly.
"You've got your mother's temper."
Caleb froze.
Vane noticed.
His smile widened.
"Ah. So Sarah finally told you."
Caleb tightened the rope.
"What do you know about my mother?"
"More than you."
Caleb stepped around the chair.
"Then talk."
Vane leaned back.
"What's it worth?"
Caleb stared.
The gunman's expression became calculating.
"Untie me. Give me a horse. I'll tell you where she went."
Caleb felt a surge of anger.
"You expect me to believe you?"
"No."
Vane smiled.
"But you want to."
Caleb looked at the revolver in his hand.
For one terrible moment, he imagined pressing the barrel against Vane's forehead and demanding the truth.
He imagined the gunman's smile disappearing.
He imagined how easily fear might loosen his tongue.
Then he remembered Harlan.
The major standing over frightened prisoners.
The easy certainty that power justified whatever a man chose to do.
Caleb lowered the revolver.
"You'll stay tied."
Vane's smile faded.
"Then you'll never know."
Caleb turned toward the door.
The gunman spoke again.
"Ask Sarah about the woman at Red Willow."
Caleb stopped.
"What woman?"
Vane leaned forward.
"The one who opened the eastern gate."
Caleb turned slowly.
Vane's eyes glittered.
"Someone helped Harlan's men enter the settlement."
Caleb stared.
The gunman smiled.
"Someone who knew the people. Someone they trusted."
Caleb felt a chill.
"Who?"
Vane's smile widened.
"Your mother."
For a moment, Caleb could not move.
Then he stepped forward.
The revolver rose in his hand.
Vane flinched.
For the first time, fear crossed his face.
Caleb stopped himself.
His breathing was hard.
His fingers trembled around the gun.
He looked at the scarred man.