I called Joel Reyes. He did not sound surprised. "We get this sometimes," he said. "Send me the letter. I'll send you the documentation."
What he sent back was the glare analysis from my original filing, plus a plain-language explanation I could actually use. The panels were made of tempered anti-reflective glass, designed specifically to absorb light rather than bounce it back. According to the manufacturer's data and Joel's own measurements, my roof produced less glare than several street-facing windows in the neighborhood — ordinary windows, on ordinary houses, that no one had ever written a letter about.
I read that paragraph twice, because it felt like the whole argument in miniature. The panels were not brighter than the street. They were dimmer. The hazard Karen described did not exist in the measurements, and the measurements were not mine. They were Joel's, and the manufacturer's, and they had been in the file since before the panels went up.
I sent a copy of Joel's documentation to the committee, with a short cover note. I kept the note polite. I did not say that Karen was inventing a problem. I said the documentation was attached, and that I was happy to answer any technical questions. I told myself that the record would do the work, and that I did not need to win the argument in the tone of my voice.
Karen did not reply to the documentation. She replied with more photographs. A week later, she was across the street again, phone raised, taking pictures in the late afternoon light, when the sun hit the roof at its lowest angle. I watched her from my front window and felt something settle in my chest, cold and clear. She was not looking for glare. She was looking for a photograph that would look like glare, and if she took enough of them, she would eventually find one.
I called Joel again, and I read him the relevant part of Karen's letter over the phone. He listened without interrupting, and then he said, "Marcus, I've stood on roofs all over this county. Your glass is the same glass we put on houses next to highways, next to schools, next to places where glare would actually matter. If your panels were hazardous, we'd know by now." He offered to come out and take fresh measurements in the same late-afternoon light Karen had photographed, and he did, a few days later, standing in my driveway with a meter while I stood beside him feeling faintly ridiculous. The readings were the same. Less glare than the windows across the street. Less glare than a parked car's windshield. I filed his note with the original analysis, and I thought, for a day or two, that numbers might finally close the subject. They did not. Karen filed the photographs anyway, as if a picture of sunlight were the same thing as a measurement of it, and the committee's file grew thicker with images and thinner with facts.
The phone call came on a weekday morning, early enough that I was still standing in my kitchen with a mug of coffee in my hand, not yet dressed for work. The number on the screen was Karen's. I almost did not answer. Then I thought about the folder of letters on my desk, and about how ignoring a committee chair never made a committee chair go away, and I picked up.
"Marcus," she said, in the bright, concerned voice she used when she was about to deliver bad news that was not, technically, her fault. "I'm calling because a neighbor has complained."
I waited. She did not go on right away, and I understood that the pause was part of the technique. She wanted me to ask who, so that she could refuse to tell me, and so that the refusal would feel like discretion rather than invention.
"About what?" I asked.
"The panels," she said. "They feel the house now looks industrial. That's the word they used. Industrial. They feel it changes the character of the street, and they're concerned about what it does to the rest of us."
"Which neighbor?" I asked.
There was another pause, shorter this time. "I can't share that," Karen said. "People need to feel safe coming to the committee. You understand. But the concern is real, Marcus. I thought you should hear it from me before it becomes formal."
I stood there with the coffee going cold in my hand and tried to keep my voice level. "If someone has a specific complaint, I'd like to address it," I said. "If it's about glare, I sent the documentation. If it's about something else, tell me what it is, and I'll look at it."