HOA Karen Climbed Onto My Roof and Started Smashing My Solar Panels — Then She Pointed the Hammer at Me Like I Was the One Breaking the Rules

Chapter 33

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"I recommend that the board void all fines issued against Mr. Grant by the architectural and compliance committee, in writing, effective immediately."

Victor Lang looked down the table. "Is there a motion?"

A board member I knew only by sight — a man named, I later learned, Harold Finch, though I will not pretend I caught his name that night — raised his hand. "So moved."

"Second," said another member.

The vote was not close. Hands went up around the table, one after another, until Victor Lang said, "The motion carries," and Osei sat back down, and a woman from the association's management office produced a letter, already prepared, on association letterhead. Victor signed it at the table. Osei signed it as well. Then Victor stood, walked to where I sat, and handed it to me.

It was short, and it was in writing, and it said what Osei had said: all fines issued against me by the architectural and compliance committee, including the $25-per-day "glare nuisance" fines, were voided, in full, effective immediately. I read it twice, standing there in front of the folding chairs, while the room waited. I folded it and put it in my jacket pocket, and I said, "Thank you," because that seemed to be the thing to say when a piece of paper finally told the truth. Behind me, I heard Priya Raman exhale, a small sound of relief, and someone else murmured approval. The fines had been a private humiliation delivered to my mailbox, one envelope at a time; hearing them voided aloud, in a room with witnesses, undid something in me that the letter alone would not have reached.

Victor nodded. "We'll move to the next item," he said.

The next item was the committee chairmanship, and the room changed when Victor Lang announced it. People shifted in their folding chairs. Someone coughed. Priya Raman sat up a little straighter in front of me. Even David Osei, who had been shuffling papers, set his pen down and folded his hands.

"The board will now consider the chairmanship of the architectural and compliance committee," Victor said. "This item was placed on the agenda following the criminal proceedings involving Ms. Whitmore, and following a petition from residents of the cul-de-sac requesting her removal from the committee."

He did not elaborate on the proceedings. He did not need to. Everyone in the room knew what had happened on my roof, and everyone in the room knew how it had ended in court. The petition had circulated the previous week, and I had signed it — not eagerly, but deliberately, the way you sign a document you have read and agree with, rather than one handed to you on a clipboard at your front door.

Victor opened the floor. A board member spoke first, a woman who lived two streets over and whose name I had never learned. She said, carefully, that the committee did important work, that standards mattered, and that the board needed to be able to trust the person chairing it. She said that trust had been damaged, and that the board could not ask residents to accept enforcement from a chair who had herself been convicted of damaging a resident's property. She sat down.

Another member spoke, more briefly. He said the board had a responsibility to the whole neighborhood, not to any one committee, and that the association could not function if its enforcement arm was led by someone the courts had just sentenced. He said he would vote for removal.

No one spoke in Karen's defense. I had expected someone to — there had been, for months, a loyal contingent on the street who agreed with her about curb appeal, who thought the panels looked wrong, who had nodded along when she talked about property values. But in that room, under the fluorescent lights, with the plea and the sentence now a matter of public record, no one stood up to defend her chairmanship. The silence was not cruel. It was simply the sound of a position that could no longer be held.

Victor called for a motion. "I move that the board remove Karen Whitmore as chair of the architectural and compliance committee, effective immediately," the first speaker said.

"Second," said another member.

Victor looked around the table. "All in favor?"

Hands went up. I counted them, because I could not help counting them, and because I wanted to remember the number correctly. Six hands. Victor counted aloud, and then he said, "Opposed?"

One hand went up, at the far end of the table — a board member who had served with Karen for years, who stared at the tabletop as he raised it, as if the vote cost him something to cast even in dissent.

News in the same category

HOA Karen Climbed Onto My Roof and Started Smashing My Solar Panels — Then She Pointed the Hammer at Me Like I Was the One Breaking the Rules

45 Part