What I learned later filled in the hours I had spent away from the street. Priya Raman told me she had seen Karen carry her bag out to the side of her own house that afternoon, moving quickly, not looking around the way she usually did when she was out on committee business. Usually Karen wanted to be seen. Usually the clipboard was held where people could read its importance. That afternoon, Priya said, Karen kept her head down. She did not stop to talk to anyone. She did not wave. She went to her garage, and a little while later her car was gone from her driveway.
Walter told me he had noticed the ladder again, later in the afternoon, but this time it was not lying in Karen's driveway. It was gone. He did not think much of it at the time. People move ladders. People borrow ladders. It was only afterward, when he put the pieces together with what the police found, that the absence meant something. A ladder that had been in one driveway in the morning was leaning against a different house in the afternoon. That is the kind of detail that sounds obvious once you know the ending, and completely unremarkable when you do not.
I stopped for gas on the way home. My phone buzzed with a work email, nothing urgent, and I left it unread until I got home. I told myself I would answer it after dinner. I told myself a lot of small, sensible things that afternoon, and none of them survived contact with the rest of the day.
The drive home took me past the entrance to Wexford Grove, past the brick sign with the neighborhood name on it in neat, confident letters. I slowed for the speed bump near the front of the development, the way everybody does, and then I took the familiar turns toward the cul-de-sac. The trees threw shade across the road in patches. A kid's bike lay on its side in a driveway. Somebody had left a recycling bin out a little too long, and I thought, without any real malice, that Karen would have had something to say about that if she had walked past it. For a second I almost smiled at the thought, because it belonged to the old version of the street, the one where her worst weapon was a letter. Then I made the last turn, and the smile went away on its own, before I had time to wonder why.
I was not thinking about her when I made the last turn. I was thinking about the groceries still in the car, and the email I had left unread, and whether I had remembered to buy coffee filters. I reached the end of the street. The houses curved around the cul-de-sac in their familiar order. My house was there, near the end, with its roof facing the street.
I turned into my street.
The police were already treating it as a crime scene by the time I had my bearings, and that was a relief I did not know how to express without sounding cold. Officer Dana Cole was the first one who spoke to me at length. She was calm in the way people are calm when they have done this before and know that calm is contagious. She asked me to start at the beginning, and I did. I told her about the sound above my head, the hammer, and the panels. I told her I had not climbed the roof, and I had not touched Karen, and I had not touched anything except my phone.
Officer Mike Brandt walked the perimeter of the house while Cole talked to me. He looked at the ladder leaning at the side of the house, the glass in the hydrangeas, and the roof, and wrote in a notebook I could not read from where I stood. When he came back, he asked if the ladder was mine. I said no; I owned a step ladder for changing light bulbs, and that was not it. He asked if I had given anyone permission to be on my roof that day, or to touch the panels. I said no to both, and the word came out flatter than I expected.
Cole took Karen's statement separately, on the far side of the driveway, where I could see her but not hear her clearly. Karen stood with her arms crossed and kept pointing at the roof while she talked, as if the roof itself were the argument. I heard the phrase "HOA enforcement" once, clearly, because she said it loudly enough to carry. Cole nodded, the way officers nod when they are listening and not agreeing, and wrote it down. Brandt bagged the hammer in a clear evidence bag. The sound of the bag sealing was very quiet, and very final.