In a committee meeting I attended that autumn, she said it more plainly than usual. We were discussing a fence application — someone else's fence, nothing to do with me — and Karen, apropos of nothing, said, "We all know what happens when the board is intimidated by a statute. They stop exercising judgment." She looked around the room as she said it, daring anyone to disagree. No one did. I sat there and understood, for the first time, what she actually believed: that the board had not decided my case on its merits, but had been frightened into approving it by state law, and by a homeowner who knew how to use that law.
She believed I had "lawyered" my way in. She said a version of that to me once, in the driveway, after a meeting, when she thought no one else was listening. "You lawyered your way in, Marcus," she said, not shouting, not even angry in the loud sense. She said it the way you state a fact about the weather. "You filed your package, you quoted your statute, and the board folded. That's not the same as being right."
I did not answer her. I did not know, then, what an answer would have accomplished. I had filed a lawful application. I had followed the process Joel had laid out for me. If that counted as lawyering, then every homeowner who read the rules before building something was a lawyer. But I could see, in her face, that she did not mean it as a description of a process. She meant it as an accusation. In her logic, I had not won. I had maneuvered. And a maneuver could be undone, if someone was willing to do the undoing herself.
That was the logic I was living next to, and I did not fully grasp it until much later. At the time, I thought it was bitterness. Bitterness, I could live with. Bitterness wrote letters. Bitterness took photographs. Bitterness did not climb onto a roof.
I thought about Richard, too, in those weeks. What I knew was only what I saw: a house where one person traveled and the other person stayed and kept order, and a street that had learned to treat Karen's order as if it were the same thing as the law. I wondered, once, what it cost her to be the person who always had to be right about the street, and then I stopped wondering, because sympathy for Karen felt like a luxury I could not afford while her letters were still arriving. I was not her friend. I was her file. And a file does not get to feel sorry for the hand that writes in it.
The "removal notice" was not something I knew about at the time. I learned about it later, in pieces, from what Karen said in meetings and from what other people told me after everything had happened, and I am careful, even now, to separate what I saw from what I was told. What I saw was this: Karen stopped sending me new kinds of letters, and started repeating the old ones, as if repetition could make them true. What I was told, later, was that she had drafted a document herself — a "removal notice," ordering the panels taken down — and that she had never sent it, and never gotten it approved by the board.
I believe that, because it fits everything else I observed. A removal notice she drafted herself would have been the perfect instrument for her logic. It would have looked official. It would have had the letterhead, and the formal language, and the signature line. It would have allowed her to tell herself that she was not acting alone, but enforcing something, even if the something had never been voted on, never been signed by anyone but her, never left her own desk drawer. She did not need the board to approve it. She needed it to exist, so that she could point to it in her own mind and say: this was authorized. This was order. This was not me. This was the committee.