still on, as if she did not intend to stay long enough to get warm.
The agenda was fought over for twenty minutes, and Susan Park held it the
way a good treasurer holds a ledger: open, and in order. A motion from the
95
floor — from Gerald Foss, who had chaired the architectural committee for
six years and had come, Peter suspected, with the speech already written in
his head — proposed that the meeting take up the election of officers before
the audit presentation, on the grounds that the membership should choose
who governed before it heard accusations. It was not a stupid motion. It had
the shape of reasonableness, which was the shape most of the trouble on this
court had worn for five years, and Susan let it be argued, both ways, from the
floor, for longer than Peter would have. Then she said, from the chair, that
the notice sent to every household had listed the audit first, and that a
meeting could no more reorder its noticed business on a voice from the floor
than a roof could be reshingled from the ridge down, and she called the
question, and the motion failed by a margin Peter estimated at four to one,
and the room settled with the sound a room makes when it has decided to
hear a thing through.
Thomas Greer, of the accounting firm, presented the audit in person. He was
a broad, unhurried man in a suit bought for courtrooms and school gyms
alike, and he had clearly done this — stood in front of angry rooms with
numbers — most of his professional life, because he did it the way Peter had
once watched a state inspector do it: he put the findings on the easel charts
one at a time, he read each figure aloud twice, and he answered every
question from the floor as if the questioner had a right to the answer, which,
Peter reflected, had not always been the custom in this room.
Sixty-three thousand four hundred dollars. He read it the second time more
slowly. Five fiscal years. Twenty-three households. He walked the room
through the reserve account and the vendor's invoices and the absence of
authorizing minutes, and when a man in the back called out that thirty-eight
thousand was a lot of money to misplace, Greer corrected him without heat:
96
it had not been misplaced. Misplaced money is found in the wrong drawer.
This money had been spent, on invoices, for services the report described in
a separate appendix, and the membership had the appendix in the envelope
on their own kitchen tables.
The foreclosure section he presented last, and he presented it the way Megan
had presented her framework: as a sequence of decisions, each one small,
each one signed. A fine assessed under a schedule never adopted. A notice
mailed to an address the association's own records showed was vacant. A lien
computed with fees that existed only in a second set of books. A sale. Three
times, Greer said, the sequence had run to its end. He did not say the word
pattern. He did not have to. He closed his folder and said that his firm
remained available to the board for the completion of the work, and sat down
to a silence that was not applause and was not its opposite — the silence of a
hundred and forty people doing arithmetic about their own street.
Then the board's chair — Susan again, because the board had asked Megan,
and Megan had said, correctly, that it should not be the president's hired
lawyer and it should not be the president's accuser's daughter either, and
then, being who she was, had accepted anyway when the room's own officers
asked her a second time, as an owner invited and not as anyone's advocate —
Megan came to the front with her own folder, which was thinner than the
auditors', and stood a moment looking at the room she had grown up riding a
bicycle through.
"I'm not going to read you the report," she said. "You've read it; it was
mailed to your house, which is more than used to happen. I want to show you
how it worked. Not the money. The method. Because the money is being
handled — there's a framework for the money, and the board has it, and the
sheriff has the rest of it. The method is the part that belongs to this room."
97
She did it the way she had done it for her father at the kitchen table in the
summer, one household at a time, without names, by house number and year.
A fine arrives in an envelope with no number on it, citing a rule in a section
that does not exist in the covenants the owner was given at closing. The
owner calls the number on the letter. The number is a vendor. The vendor
explains the fine and offers a way to make it stop: a Compliance Agreement,
a signature, a monthly courtesy — her phrase, delivered flat — folded into
the dues. The owner signs, because the owner has a job and a family and a
finite amount of fight, and because the alternative named in the second letter
is a lien. Or the owner does not sign, and the fines continue, numbered by
nobody, appealable to nobody, until the lien arrives in its turn, computed in a
set of books the owner has never seen.
"A fine," Megan said. "A signature. A lien. A door closing." She let it sit.
"Twenty-three times, in five years, on this court and the two streets that feed