past the eye the way water slides past a stone, the homeowner waived — the
word was irrevocably — any right to appeal, contest, dispute, or seek hearing
regarding any fine, fee, penalty, or assessment heretofore or hereafter
imposed under the Declaration, and agreed that the association's
determination in any such matter would be final and binding and not subject
to review. There was a signature line for him. There was a signature line for
a witness. There was a notary block at the bottom, with the jurat already
typed: they wanted his signature sworn. They wanted it witnessed, notarized,
and permanent — a confession with a seal on it, good against every fine they
had levied and every fine they had not levied yet.
Many of your fellow homeowners have found it convenient. He sat with that
sentence for a while, and with the notary block, and he thought about the
kept lawns and the clean street and the people at the hardware store bagging
his screws and telling him, in the way people tell you a bridge is out ahead,
to read everything twice. He thought about how many doors on Sycamore
Court a pad of pink-duplicate forms could knock on in a year, and how many
kitchen tables a document like this one could be slid across, with a pen laid
beside it like a courtesy, and how few of those tables would have a man at
them who had read the Declaration with a pencil and counted its articles
twice.
19
He got the logbook down. Friday, March 21, he wrote. Rain, 44 degrees.
Certified mail rec'd, Second Notice, fines doubled to $2,500, plus new item,
failure to permit inspection, $750. Total $3,250. Cover letter over signature
of D. Kessler, President, offering enclosed Compliance Agreement to close
file. Agreement reviewed in full. Terms: admission of violations as cited;
consent to fines as assessed; waiver, irrevocable, of all rights of appeal or
hearing for any fine past or future. Notary block pre-typed. He stopped there,
with the pencil resting on the page, and listened to the rain work at the
gutters of his mother's house, and then he wrote the day's last entry, in the
same small exact hand, a sentence that was not a description of anything and
that he underlined once, the way he had once underlined a clause in a
covenant because it was well drafted — except that this sentence was his.
They are not collecting fines. They are collecting signatures.
The letter took him three evenings to write, which was not because the
writing was hard. It was the deciding what to ask for that took the evenings,
because Peter had spent twenty-six years on the other side of requests like
this one, and he knew that a records request was not a question. It was a net.
You decided the size of the holes before you threw it.
He wrote it at the kitchen table, in the bound logbook first, in pencil, the way
he drafted everything that mattered, with his mother's old reading lamp
pulled close and the compliance folder open beside him like a second
witness. Outside the window Sycamore Court went through its April
evening: sprinklers ticking bravely on two lawns, a dog being walked in a
slow arc, the streetlights coming on at seven-forty, which he noted without
deciding to. Noting was what he did instead of other things. It had been his
20
profession. It was becoming his character, and he was aware of the
difference, and he noted that too.
The Ohio Planned Community Act was not long, as statutes went, and he had
read it twice through by the second evening. Section 5312.05. Owners' rights
to examine the books and records of the association. It was all there in the
flat language of the Revised Code: the financial records, the meeting
minutes, the contracts, kept and made available. An association was not a
government. It only got to act like one to the extent that people let it keep its
papers in the dark.
His request, when he typed it on the fourth morning — he typed final
versions, two copies, one for the file — asked for five things, and he
numbered them the way he had numbered conditions on inspection reports
for twenty-six years, because numbering was a courtesy you did to the future,
which would otherwise have to guess.
One: all contracts between the Wrenfield Estates Homeowners' Association
and any vendor providing enforcement, compliance, or collection services,
current and for the preceding five years. Two: the association's fine ledgers
and violation records for the same period, showing amounts assessed,
collected, and disposition. Three: all payments to any such vendor, with
invoices. Four: the minutes of all board meetings at which enforcement
contracts, fine schedules, or vendor payments were approved. Five: the
association's current financial statements, budgets, and reserve studies.
He read it over and added a sixth item, because the thinking had shown him
the hole in the net: all correspondence concerning a document titled
Compliance Agreement, with copies of all such agreements executed in the
preceding five years, names redacted at the association's discretion. He did
not think they would honor it. He thought the refusal would be informative,
21
and he wrote that in the logbook too, because a logbook was not a diary. It
was a deposition you gave to yourself, one day at a time, and it had to
survive being read aloud by a stranger.
The letter went certified mail, return receipt requested, to the association's
registered address, which was Doreen Kessler's house, number 3, because the