"The police came again the next morning," Judith said. "I showed them the envelope. I told them about the man in the uniform. I told them about the cabinet, and the papers, and the phone shutting down. I told them the exact time. Three seventeen. I told them everything, and they walked through the house again, and they looked at the front door again, and they told me there was no forced entry. The lock was intact. The windows were intact. Nothing was broken. One of them asked me if I had been taking my medication. The other one asked me if I had anyone who could stay with me for a few days. They suggested — very kindly, very gently — that grief was affecting my memory. That was the phrase they used. Grief was affecting my memory. As if grief could open a jewellery box and take a folder of medical records and leave wet footprints on my floor and walk through my living room at 3:17 in the morning in a dark utility uniform."
Her voice did not rise. That was what made it so hard to listen to. She was not shouting. She was not crying. She was telling me, calmly, that the people who were supposed to protect her had decided she was confused, and that the man who had come into her house had counted on exactly that.
"I did not argue with them," she said. "I had already learned that arguing made it worse. The more certain I sounded, the more worried they looked, and the more worried they looked, the more certain they were that I was not well. So I thanked them. I walked them to the door. I locked it behind them. And I sat down in my living room and I thought about what to do next, because I knew he would come back. He had told me to stop watching the houses across the street. That meant he knew I had been watching. That meant he knew I had seen something. And that meant he would come back to make sure I stopped."
She paused, and she looked at the envelope on the coffee table, and then she looked back at me.
"The next afternoon," she said, "Guardian Key came to my house. I had not called them. I had not asked them to come. A technician knocked on my door and told me they had detected a malfunction in my lock and they were replacing it as a courtesy, free of charge, no appointment necessary. He was polite. He was efficient. He had the new lock installed in less than twenty minutes, and he showed me how it worked, and he gave me a card with a number to call if I had any problems, and he left. And after he left, I went to check the recordings from the previous night. I wanted to see if the camera had caught the man, even if my phone had not. And every recording from the previous night had been deleted."
I stared at her. "Every recording?"
"Every one," she said. "The whole night. Gone. Not just the hours when he was in the house. The whole night. As if the night had never happened. I called Guardian Key and I asked them about it, and the woman on the phone told me that when a lock is replaced, the system sometimes resets, and recordings can be lost during a reset. She said it very smoothly, as if she had said it many times before. I asked her why they had replaced a lock I had not reported as broken. She said they had detected a malfunction remotely. I asked her what malfunction. She said she did not have that information. I asked her to speak to a supervisor. She said a supervisor would call me back. No one ever called me back."
I thought about my own lock then, the Guardian Key lock on my own front door, the one Sophie and I used every day without thinking about it, the one I had trusted because it was new and expensive and because everyone on Maple Crossing had one. I thought about how easy it would be for someone to open a door that was designed to be opened remotely, and how easy it would be for someone to erase the proof that it had ever been opened, and I felt sick in a way I had not felt sick since the morning I found the glass.
"Judith," I said, "why didn't you come to me then? Why didn't you tell me any of this before this morning?"