"There is no apology," I said, because there had not been one, and I needed to hear myself say it out loud. "You are not even claiming this was an accident."
"It was not an accident," she said. She said it plainly, without hesitation, and that was worse than an apology would have been, because an apology would have meant she had made a mistake, and this was not a mistake. This was deliberate. She had carried a heavy sack down the street in the dark, she had checked both ends of the street, she had emptied it across my porch, she had looked into my camera, and she had done all of it on purpose, and now she was standing there telling me so.
I looked down at the glass again. Hundreds of fragments. I thought about what would have happened if I had opened the door without looking, if I had stepped out in my bare feet to get the newspaper, if Sophie had come downstairs first and run out to the porch the way she sometimes did on a school morning, half asleep, her shoes still by the door. I thought about her feet, and the glass, and the blood, and my hands tightened on the door frame until my knuckles went white.
"Why?" I asked. "Why my house? Why my porch? What did I do to you, Judith? I have lived here eight years. I have never—"
She did not let me finish. Her head turned, sharp and sudden, and she looked past me, past the house, toward the far end of the street, and I followed her gaze without thinking, and I saw it. A gray sedan. It was parked at the far end of the street, near the corner, with its engine running. I could not see the driver. I could not see a license plate from that distance, not in that light, but I could see the faint shimmer of exhaust in the cold air, and I could see that the car was facing away from us, facing the way out of Maple Crossing, and as I watched, it pulled away. It did not speed. It did not screech. It pulled away smoothly and quietly, as if it had only been waiting for a signal, and within seconds it was gone around the corner, and the street was empty again.
Judith watched it go. Her whole body was turned toward it, her shoulders tight, her hand gripping the folded sack so hard that the fabric bunched in her fist, and when the car was gone she turned back to me, and I saw that her hands were trembling. Not shaking. Trembling. The fine, constant trembling of a person who has been holding herself together for a long time and is starting to come apart at the edges.
"Now call the police," she said. Her voice was still steady, but her hands gave her away, and I could see the tremor in her fingers, and I could see the way she kept glancing toward the corner where the sedan had been, as if she expected it to come back.
I looked at my phone. I looked at the glass. I looked at Judith, standing on my lawn in her pajamas, trembling, telling me to call the police, and I felt the ground shift under me, the way it does when a story you thought you understood turns out to be a different story entirely. I had woken up thinking I was the victim of a spiteful neighbour, a woman with a grudge, a prank, a warning, something small and mean and explainable. But spiteful neighbours do not ask you to call the police. They do not look into your camera on purpose. They do not watch a gray sedan pull away and then tremble.
"Judith," I said, more quietly now, because the anger was draining out of me and something else was taking its place, something colder and more careful. "What is going on?"
She did not answer that. She stepped closer to the porch, but she did not step onto it, she stopped at the bottom step, and she looked up at me, and her eyes were wide now, and urgent, and she said, "While you are waiting, listen to me. Do not sweep it up. Do not touch it. Do not move a single piece of it. Do you understand me? Not one fragment."
I nodded, slowly, because I did not understand, not really, but I understood that she meant it, and that she was frightened, and that frightened people do not give instructions like that unless the instructions matter.
"And when the police come," she went on, her voice dropping lower, "do not let the first person who arrives into your house."