"I tried," she said. "That is what I have been trying to tell you, Calvin. I tried to warn you. The day after the lock was replaced, I wrote you a letter. I wrote down everything that had happened — the jewellery box, the medical records, the footprints, the man at 3:17, the envelope, the lock, the deleted recordings. I put it in an envelope and I walked across the street and I put it in your mailbox. I watched you come home that evening. I watched you take the mail out of the box and carry it inside. And the next morning, when I saw you in the yard, you did not say anything about it. You waved. You smiled. You asked me how I was doing. And I realised you had never seen the letter. Someone had taken it out of your mailbox before you read it, or after you brought it inside — I don't know which, and I don't know how — but the letter was gone, and you did not know, and I did not know how to tell you again without sounding like the woman the police already thought I was."
She folded her hands again, and she looked down at them, and when she spoke again her voice was quieter.
"I called your phone twice," she said. "Both times, the call disconnected before you answered. The first time, I heard it ring once, and then there was silence, and then the call ended. The second time, it did not even ring. It went straight to silence. I called from my house phone, and I called from my mobile, and both times the same thing happened. I do not know how that is possible. I am not a cybersecurity expert. Edwin was. Edwin was a cybersecurity consultant, and he used to tell me that the things people believe are impossible are usually just things they have not looked at closely enough. He used to say that if someone wants to keep two people from talking to each other, there are a dozen ways to do it, and most of them do not leave a mark. I did not understand what he meant then. I understand it now."
I wanted to tell her that she was wrong, that the calls must have been a bad signal, that the letter must have been lost, that there had to be an ordinary explanation for all of it. I wanted to, because the alternative was too large and too close to home, and it involved my daughter sleeping upstairs in a house with a lock I no longer trusted. But I could not say it, because I had found broken glass on my own porch that morning, and because the wooden box had been moved, and because Judith had warned me that someone had been coming inside while we slept, and because everything she was telling me fit together too neatly to be grief, or confusion, or coincidence. Grief does not delete camera recordings. Grief does not replace a lock you never reported as broken. Grief does not take a letter out of a mailbox.
"Tell me the rest," I said. "Please. Tell me everything."
Judith nodded. She took another breath, and I could see her gathering herself, the way she had gathered herself at the beginning, and I knew that what came next was the part she had been most afraid to say out loud.
"The previous Friday," she said, "I was in my front yard. It was late in the afternoon, and I was watering the roses, and I looked across the street, and I saw him. The same man. The same dark utility uniform. He was in your yard, Calvin. He had opened your side gate, and he was standing beneath Sophie's bedroom window."
The words hit me like a physical blow. I stopped breathing for a second. Sophie's bedroom window. My daughter's window. A man in a dark uniform standing beneath it, in my yard, in the late afternoon, while I was still at work and Sophie was at school, or home alone doing her homework, or — I did not know. I did not know what day it had been, or what time, or whether Sophie had been home, and the not knowing was worse than anything Judith had told me so far.
"He was not doing anything," Judith said quickly, as if she could see what I was thinking. "He was just standing there. Looking up at the window. He had one hand on the wall, and the other hand was holding something — I could not see what it was. A tool, perhaps. Or a phone. I do not know. I put down the watering can and I walked to the fence, and I called out to him. I asked him what he was doing in your yard. I told him that this was not his house, and that he had no business being there, and that I was going to call the police."
She stopped, and she shook her head, slowly, as if she still could not believe what had happened next.