I Caught My Neighbor Dumping Broken Glass Outside My Front Door — I Had No Idea What She Was Really Trying to Do

Chapter 9

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Someone has been coming into my house," she said. "Not once. Four times. And I need you to understand that I am not confused, and I am not imagining it, and I am not — " She stopped. She swallowed. "The police told me grief was affecting my memory. I want you to hear what actually happened before you decide whether to believe them or me."

I nodded. I did not say anything. I thought of the glass on my porch that morning, the broken pieces catching the light at 6:14, and the wooden box moved, and the Guardian Key locks at nineteen homes, and I thought of how Judith had warned me that someone had been coming inside while we slept. I had not asked her then what she meant. I was asking her now, with my whole attention, and she knew it.

"The first time," she said, "it was a jewellery box. It sat on my dresser for thirty years. Edwin gave it to me. It was not valuable, not in the way a thief would care about. A few pieces of costume jewellery, a brooch my mother wore, things like that. I keep it closed. I always keep it closed. One morning I came downstairs and went back up to get my earrings, and the box was open. The lid was up. Everything was still inside. Nothing was taken. I stood there looking at it, and I told myself I must have left it open the night before, even though I knew I had not. I knew the way you know your own habits. I closed it. I did not tell anyone. I thought I was being foolish."

She paused, and her fingers tightened together in her lap.

"The second time, it was Edwin's medical records. He kept them in a folder in the cabinet in the study. I knew exactly where they were because I had put them there myself after he died, in the order he liked, with the most recent ones on top. One afternoon I went to look for a letter from his doctor, and the folder was gone. Not the whole cabinet. Just that folder. I searched the house. I searched every drawer, every shelf, every box in the attic. It was gone. I called the doctor's office and asked for copies, and the woman on the phone was kind about it, and I told myself I must have misplaced it, even though I had never misplaced anything in that house in forty years. I did not tell anyone that either. I was embarrassed. I thought grief was doing something to my head, and I did not want anyone else to think so too."

I watched her face as she spoke. She was not rambling. She was not jumping from one thing to another. She was laying it out in order, the way a person does when they have gone over it so many times that the order has become a kind of anchor.

"The third time," she said, "there was no doubt left. It had rained the night before, and when I came downstairs in the morning there were wet footprints on the floor. They started at the front door and they went straight through the living room to the basement door. They were not mine. I had been in bed all night. I had not gone downstairs. I had not gone outside. The footprints were large, a man's shoes, and they were wet, and they stopped at the basement door, and the basement door was open a crack, and I had locked it the night before. I know I locked it, Calvin. I lock that door every single night. I have locked it every single night since Edwin died, because the basement is where his laboratory equipment is, and where his files are, and I did not want anyone going down there."

She stopped again, and this time she looked toward the hallway, toward the stairs, as if she were listening for Sophie.

"I stood in the living room looking at those footprints," she said, "and I understood that someone had been in my house while I slept. I understood that they had walked through my living room. I understood that they had gone to the basement. And I understood that I had slept through all of it, upstairs, in my bed, with my door closed, and I had heard nothing. That was the worst part. Not the footprints. The fact that I had heard nothing."

I leaned forward. "Did you call the police then?"

News in the same category

I Caught My Neighbor Dumping Broken Glass Outside My Front Door — I Had No Idea What She Was Really Trying to Do

45 Part