I looked at Lily and Sophie on the rug. Lily had built the tower up to her chin now, and Sophie was handing her blocks one by one, carefully, like they were precious. They looked like sisters. They looked like they had always been sisters. Lily was four, with Vanessa's dark hair and my eyes. Sophie was six, thin and pale, with Daniel's birthmark under her ear and Daniel's serious mouth. If Daniel had lived, this is what his daughter would have looked like. If Daniel had lived, Sophie would have had a home, and a school, and a bedroom with a window, instead of a hidden room behind a closet wall.
"Is Sophie my sister?" Lily asked suddenly, looking up from her tower. "Is she my sister, Daddy? Because she sleeps in my closet and she shares my toys and she calls you Daddy too."
I went over and sat on the rug beside them. My knees cracked. I put one arm around Lily and one arm around Sophie, and Sophie leaned into me without hesitation, like she had been waiting her whole life for someone to hold her like that.
"She is your cousin," I said. "She is your Uncle Daniel's little girl. Uncle Daniel was my big brother, and he loved you very much, even though he never got to meet you. And Sophie is family. She is our family. And she is not going back into that wall. Not tonight. Not ever."
Sophie looked up at me. "Is Grandpa coming?" she whispered. "Grandpa said if I come out, he will be angry. Grandpa said I have to stay hidden or the bad people will take me away."
"There are no bad people coming for you," I told her, and I tried to make my voice steady and sure, even though my heart was pounding. "I am here. Your Aunt Vanessa is here. Your Grandma is here. Lily is here. Nobody is going to take you away. And your grandpa is not going to hurt you. Do you understand?"
She nodded, but she did not look convinced. She curled her fingers around my shirt again and pressed her face against my arm. Lily patted her back, the way Vanessa patted Lily's back when she had a bad dream, and said, "It's okay, Sophie. Daddy will keep us safe. Daddy keeps everybody safe."
I wished I believed her. I wished I believed that I could keep everybody safe, because right now I felt like the least safe person in the world. My father was alive and living in my walls. My brother's daughter had been hidden in my house for two years. My wife and my mother had lied to me, out of fear, out of love, out of a desperate need to protect Lily, and I understood why they had done it, and I was furious with them anyway, and I was furious with myself for not seeing it, for not noticing the food disappearing, for not hearing the sounds in the walls, for living in that house for five years and never once wondering what was behind my daughter's closet.
Vanessa came and sat beside me on the rug. She did not touch me at first. She just sat close enough that our shoulders were almost touching, and she looked at the girls, and she said, very quietly, "I am so sorry, Ryan. I wanted to tell you a hundred times. Every day I wanted to tell you. I used to lie awake at night and practice how I would say it. But every time I got close, I would hear him moving in the walls, or Sophie would tell Lily something he said, and I would lose my nerve. I thought I was keeping Lily safe. I thought I was keeping Sophie alive. I didn't know what else to do."
I took her hand. Her fingers were cold. I held them between both of mine to warm them.
"I know," I said. "I know why you did it. I would have done the same thing if I thought it would keep Lily safe. I am not angry at you. I am angry at him. I am angry at my father for doing this to all of us. For faking his death. For stealing Sophie. For hiding in our house and threatening my wife and my daughter. He does not get to do that anymore. He does not get to live in the walls and scare little girls and control this family from the dark."
My mother was crying openly now, her shoulders shaking. "I should have told you the night he came to my door," she said. "I should have called the police right then. I was a coward. I let him frighten me. I let him use Lily to keep me quiet. I am so sorry, Ryan. I am so sorry."
"Mom," I said. "We are going to fix this. All of us. Together. No more secrets. No more walls. Sophie is going to have a real bedroom and a real school and a real life. Lily is going to be safe. Vanessa is never going to have to be afraid in her own house again. And my father is going to have to answer for what he did. All of it."
"Before I could answer her, Sophie spoke, very softly, from the rug. 'Grandpa built the rooms,' she said. 'He told me he built them when the house was new, before you lived there, Daddy. He said there are doors that look like walls, and a little kitchen, and a bed, and books. He said it was our secret castle. He said if I am very good and very quiet, one day I can come out and live in the sunshine like Lily.'