We talked for a long time, in that small room, about Hale, about the documents, about what we would do when he came. Thomas told us everything he knew about Hale's habits, his weaknesses, his vanity. Hale liked to think of himself as a gentleman, Thomas said. He liked to believe he was reasonable, civilized, a man who could be negotiated with. That was his weakness. He believed his own story. He believed that if he was polite enough, if he was patient enough, people would give him what he wanted, because they would be afraid of what would happen if they did not.
"He will come to the door," Thomas said. "He will knock, and he will smile, and he will pretend to be something he is not. A buyer. A neighbor. An old friend of the family. He will ask to come in. And when he is inside, he will drop the act, and he will tell you what he wants, and he will give you a deadline, and he will make it very clear what will happen if you do not meet it."
"How do you know?" I asked.
"Because he did it to me," Thomas said. "Eighteen years ago, he came to my office, and he sat in the chair across from my desk, and he smiled, and he told me he knew what I had found, and he told me that if I went to the police, my family would pay the price. He gave me forty-eight hours. Forty-eight hours to give him the documents and walk away. I gave him something else instead. I gave him a funeral."
The room went quiet. Sophie was listening, her doll in her lap, her eyes wide. I could see she was frightened, but she was also listening very carefully, the way children listen when they know something important is being said, even if they do not fully understand it.
"Sophie," Thomas said gently, turning to her. "Do you remember where the documents are? Do you remember what your father taught you?"
Sophie nodded. "Daddy taught me the song," she said. "He taught me the song about the house, so I would never forget."
"What song?" I asked.
Sophie looked at me, and then she began to sing, very softly, in a clear, small voice. It was a simple tune, the kind of song a father makes up for his daughter when she is small, about a house with a secret, and a wall with a heart, and a picture that hides a treasure. As she sang, Thomas closed his eyes, and Margaret put a hand to her mouth, and Vanessa reached for my hand, and I understood, even before Sophie finished, that Daniel had taught his daughter a song so she would always know where the proof was hidden, even if everyone else who knew was gone.
When she finished, Sophie looked at me and said, "The pictures, Uncle Ryan. Behind the pictures. Daddy said the house keeps its secrets behind the pictures, where nobody looks because they think they already know what's there."
Thomas nodded. "The photograph wall," he said. "In the hallway downstairs. Behind it, there is a hollow, a space I built into the wall when the house was first renovated. Inside it, there is a tin box, wrapped in Daniel's old jacket. Inside the box are the documents. Every one of them. The bank records. The contracts with my forged signature. The account numbers. The names of the people Hale paid. All of it. Enough to put him in prison for the rest of his life."
"Show me," I said.
Sophie stood up, and she took my hand, and she led me out of the small room, through the passage, into Lily's closet, and out into the hallway. Vanessa and Thomas and Margaret followed, and Lily, who had been playing with her dolls, looked up and said, "Sophie!" with delight, and ran to her, and the two girls hugged, and for a moment, in the middle of all that fear and planning, there was something simple and good. Two cousins, meeting in the light, in the open, for the first time, without a wall between them.
But Sophie did not stop to play. She led me down the stairs, her small hand in mine, her steps confident, as if she had walked this path a hundred times in her mind, even if she had never walked it in the open before. She led me to the hallway downstairs, to the wall where our family photographs hung in a row, pictures of me as a boy, of Daniel, of my parents on their wedding day, of Lily as a baby. Sophie stopped in front of them, and she looked up at me, and she said, "This one."
She pointed to a photograph of Daniel and me, taken when we were boys, standing in the back yard, our arms around each other, grinning at the camera, our faces sunburned, our hair messy. I remembered that day. I remembered the tree behind us, and the way Daniel had dared me to climb it, and the way I had done it, even though I was scared, because he was my brother and he believed I could.
Sophie reached up, and with Thomas's help, we took the photograph down from the wall. Behind it, where the plaster should have been solid, there was a panel, almost invisible, the same color as the wall, with a tiny seam around its edge. Thomas pressed on one corner, and the panel clicked, and swung open, revealing a hollow space inside the wall, dark and cool.