Vanessa came downstairs a little later, her hair pulled back, her face pale in the morning light. She did not say good morning. She poured coffee and stood beside me at the window, and for a while we just stood there together, two people who had been married for years and had only just started telling each other the truth.
"He will come today," she said finally. "Won't he?"
"I don't know," I said. "Thomas says he likes to take his time. He likes to let you know he is there before he makes his move. He wants you scared first."
"I'm already scared," she said.
"I know," I said. "Me too."
She looked at me then, really looked at me, and I saw something in her eyes I had not seen in a long time. Not just fear. Resolve. "I need to tell you everything," she said. "Not the short version. All of it. The two years. All of it."
I nodded. "Tell me."
We sat at the kitchen table, and Vanessa told me. She told me about the first time she had heard the sound behind the wall, a small sound, like a child shifting in her sleep, and how she had told herself she was imagining it. She told me about the night she had finally followed the sound and found the loose panel in Lily's closet, and the narrow passage behind it, and the small girl with my birthmark standing in the dark, holding a doll made from a sock. She told me how Sophie had looked at her and whispered, "Are you my aunt?" and how Vanessa's hands had shaken so hard she could barely hold the flashlight. She told me about Thomas stepping out of the shadows, older, thinner, his hair white, his eyes the same eyes I remembered from my childhood, and how he had put a finger to his lips and said, "Please. If you love your daughter, do not scream."
She told me how he had explained it to her that night, in a whisper, while Sophie slept in a little bed at the end of the passage. How Daniel had died, not in the accident everyone believed, but in a fire that had been set to look like an accident, a fire that had been meant for Thomas. How Thomas had found Daniel's body and had known, in that moment, that if he stayed and fought Marcus Hale in the open, Hale would kill Sophie too, and Margaret, and anyone else who stood in his way. So Thomas had done the only thing he could think of. He had disappeared. He had let the world believe he was dead. He had hidden in his own house, in the passages he had built into the walls when he was a young man, back when the house was his and the company was his and he had thought a secret room was a clever thing to have, not a place to live for eighteen years.
"He told me Daniel had left Sophie with him the day before he died," Vanessa said, her voice breaking. "Daniel knew something was wrong. He knew Hale was closing in. He brought Sophie here and he said, 'Dad, if anything happens to me, keep her safe. Don't trust anyone. Not even Ryan. Not yet.' And then he was gone, and Thomas kept her, and he kept her safe, and he raised her in the dark because the light was too dangerous."
"Why didn't he tell me?" I asked. "Why didn't he trust me?"
Vanessa reached across the table and took my hand. "Because he was afraid for you too. He said if you knew, you would try to fight Hale, and Hale would kill you. He said the only way to keep you alive was to keep you ignorant. He said it was the hardest thing he had ever done, watching you grieve for him, watching you bury an empty coffin, and never once letting you know he was ten feet away, listening to you cry."
I thought about that. I thought about the funeral, about standing in the rain in a black suit, about my mother's hand on my arm, about the terrible, hollow feeling of lowering a box into the ground and knowing that the man inside it was supposed to be my father. I thought about all the years after, about the birthdays and the holidays and the ordinary days when I had wished, just once, that I could ask him a question, or hear his laugh, or tell him about Lily. He had been there. All that time, he had been there, behind the walls, listening, and I had never known.
"I hated him for a while," Vanessa said quietly. "When I first found them, I hated him. I thought, how could you do this to your son? How could you do this to your wife? Margaret grieved for you for eighteen years, Thomas. She cried at night. I heard her. And you were right there, and you said nothing."
"What did he say?" I asked.