I knelt down beside her again. 'How long have you lived in there, Sophie? Do you remember living anywhere else?'
She thought about it, her small brow furrowing. 'I remember a lady with soft hands,' she said. 'She sang to me. Then she went to sleep and did not wake up. Then Grandpa came, and he held me, and he said we had to go somewhere safe. We drove a long time. Then we came to the house, and he showed me the little rooms, and he said this was our new home. He brings me food. He teaches me to read. He tells me stories about my daddy. He says my daddy was brave and strong, and that he looks just like you.'
My throat closed. Daniel. She was describing Daniel, and she was describing me, and in her mind the two of us had blurred into one man, a father who was coming back for her, a father who would keep her safe. Thomas had taught her that. He had taken a grieving little girl who had lost both her parents and he had given her a story to hold onto, a story in which her father was still alive and just out of reach, waiting behind a wall. It was cruel, and it was kind, and it was the most twisted thing I had ever heard, and I did not know whether to hate my father for it or to pity the broken old man who had done it because he did not know any other way to keep his granddaughter close.
'What does he eat?' I asked. 'Where does he get food? Does he ever leave the house?'
Sophie shook her head. 'He eats what I eat. Sometimes he goes out at night, when everyone is sleeping. He has a little door in the back, behind the garden shed. He says the night is his friend. He says the night keeps secrets.'
Vanessa nodded slowly. 'That explains the missing food from the kitchen,' she said. 'Not just Lily's snacks. I used to think I was forgetting things. A can of soup. A loaf of bread. A carton of milk, gone in a day. I thought I was losing my mind. I started writing lists. The lists never matched. And the back door, Ryan, remember how the lock used to stick? I thought it was just old. I bet he was using it. I bet he was coming and going right under our noses for years.'
My mother spoke then, her voice low and tired. 'He built the house, Ryan. Not with his own hands, not alone, but he was the one who drew the plans. He was an engineer. He loved secret spaces. When we were first married, he used to joke about building a hidden room for our children to play in, a pirate hideout, a castle. I thought it was just talk. I never knew he actually did it. I never knew he put doors inside the walls and rooms behind the closets. He must have built them when the house was being finished, before we moved in, and never told anyone. Not me. Not Daniel. Not you. He kept it for himself, like he kept everything else for himself in the end.'
I thought about my father, the man I had mourned for eighteen years. I remembered him teaching me to throw a baseball in the backyard. I remembered him carrying me on his shoulders at a county fair. I remembered him sitting at the kitchen table with blueprints spread out in front of him, a pencil behind his ear, explaining to Daniel and me how a bridge held itself up, how a building stood against the wind. He had been a good father, once. Or at least, I had believed he was a good father, once. And then one icy night, when I was sixteen, the police had come to our door and told us that his car had gone off the road and into a river, and that they had not found his body, and that they were sorry, and my mother had collapsed in the hallway, and Daniel had held me while I cried, and we had buried an empty casket because there was nothing else to bury.
Except he had not died. He had staged it. He had driven his car off the road on purpose, or he had abandoned it there, and he had walked away from his wife and his two sons and started a new life somewhere else, for reasons I still did not understand. Had he been in debt? Had he been in trouble? Had he simply grown tired of being a husband and a father and decided to be someone else? I had spent eighteen years grieving a man who had chosen to leave us, and now that man was living in the walls of my house, raising my dead brother's daughter in the dark, threatening my wife and my little girl to keep his secret safe.
'Did he ever say why he left?' I asked my mother. 'Did he ever explain why he faked his death? Did he ever say he was sorry?'
My mother shook her head. 'He said he had made mistakes. He said he owed money to the wrong people. He said it was safer for us if the world thought he was dead. He said he had watched over us from a distance, all those years. He said he saw you graduate, Ryan. He said he stood in the back of the church at your wedding. He said he watched Lily being born from a hospital waiting room, and that he cried when he heard her first cry through the door. He said he loved us. He said he had never stopped loving us. And then he asked me to help him hide Sophie, and he told me that if I said no, he would take her and go, and I would never see her again, and neither would you.'