Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

Chapter 20

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

It was not. A local columnist obtained the broad shape of her cooperation within days and wrote that Caroline Whitmore, of the department store video, was now informing on her own husband to save herself. Old friends stopped calling in a new way, not the frightened way of the arrest week, but a cooler way, as if cooperation had confirmed something unseemly about her character that the original scandal had only suggested. At her club, her locker was emptied and its contents shipped to the hotel in two boxes, with a note from the manager expressing regret and the hope that she would think of the club fondly.

She resigned from the foundation on a single sheet of paper she wrote herself, three sentences, no adjectives she had not earned. Her attorney read it and said it was blunter than necessary. She sent it anyway.

The restaurant was her attorney's idea. She had begun eating dinner off room service trays, and he told her, not unkindly, that hiding was starting to look like a position.

So she went to lunch, alone, at a place two blocks from the hotel where she had once known the owner and the menu by heart. The hostess seated her without visible reaction, which felt like mercy. She ordered soup. She was reading the cooperation agreement summary her attorney had marked for her when a young man at the bar turned on his stool, looked at her for a long moment, and called out, clearly and happily, for the whole room:

"Karen!"

A few people laughed. Someone at a corner table lifted a phone, then lowered it. The soup arrived during the silence that followed, set down by a waiter who did not look at her face at all.

Caroline paid for a meal she had not eaten. In the lobby her hands were shaking too hard to manage the clasp of her handbag, and she stood by a potted palm, doing it slowly, twice.

She did not tell herself it was the worst thing that had ever happened to a person. That was the strange education of those weeks: even humiliated, standing in a hotel restaurant with soup on her breath and strangers laughing, she could measure the borders of her own experience with new accuracy. Her version of being judged before she was known had an end date on it, somewhere. The story would age. She had money, lawyers, a door that locked. She could move to another city and become, in time, a woman people half recognized.

Simone Bennett could not move out of her own skin to get away from an assumption. Neither could the people Caroline was beginning, belatedly, to picture in other stores: a man asked to empty his pockets at a pharmacy counter, a woman followed down an aisle by an employee pretending to straighten shelves. Their afternoons did not come with indictments and attorneys to give them shape. They just had to go home and carry it, the way Simone had carried hers out of Bellmont and Avery with a receipt in her handbag.

The fairness of her own treatment was not the part that stayed with her that night. The part that stayed was that it had taken being laughed at in a restaurant for her to feel, in her body and not as an idea, what she had done with a telephone in a department store. She had turned suspicion into a public event for another woman, and called it protecting the store. The store had not been in danger. It was the only thing in the building that day which had been perfectly safe.

Amelia called the following Tuesday to say the sessions were complete for now, that her testimony would be scheduled around the trial calendar, and that she should keep the calendars and the laptop untouched.

"Is that everything?" Caroline asked.

"For our purposes. What you do with the rest of it is no longer an investigative question."

She sat in the hotel room a long time after that, among the boxes from her club and the three suitcases. Then she went downstairs, got into her car for the first time since the Saturday at Bellmont and Avery, a Saturday which now seemed to belong to a different administration of her life, and drove across the river with both hands at ten and two like a girl at her first lesson.

The store was lit as it always was, marble and glass and calm, indifferent to whether the woman approaching its door was a customer, a defendant, or a penitent. Caroline parked. She sat a moment with the engine off, rehearsing nothing, because she had learned at last what rehearsed certainty had cost, and then she got out, crossed the pavement, and walked in.

News in the same category

Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

30 Part