Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

By seven on Sunday morning, the video had been watched six hundred thousand times, and Simone Bennett had not seen a single second of it.

Maya told her the number at the kitchen table, reading from her phone with the careful neutrality of a news anchor.

"Six hundred and twelve thousand," Maya said. "That was four minutes ago. It is probably worse now."

"Worse is a judgment," Simone said. "The number is a number."

"The comments are worse."

"Then stop reading the comments."

"I am conducting research."

"You are seventeen. Conduct it after breakfast."

Maya set the phone face down, which in her household was a recognized act of diplomacy. Outside the window the street was doing its ordinary Sunday things. A man Simone knew slightly was walking a dog that clearly made the decisions. Nothing in the neighborhood suggested that, on the other side of a screen, strangers were replaying the worst forty minutes of Simone's year in loops, pausing it, zooming it, narrating it.

She had slept badly and in sections. She kept returning, at three and then again at four, to the sound of her own voice at the register. It had stayed level. She was obscurely grateful for that and then annoyed at herself for the gratitude, because a level voice was not a prize a person should have to win for buying a suit in a department store. She had lain in the dark and catalogued the afternoon the way she catalogued everything, in order, and what she kept arriving at was not the accusation. It was the arithmetic of it. Three garments. Two garments. A conclusion built out of subtraction by a woman who had never once asked where the third one had gone.

"You are doing the face," Maya said.

"What face."

"The face where you are cross-examining the toast."

Simone put the knife down. "Eat your eggs."

"They are your eggs. You made too many, as a coping mechanism."

"I made a normal quantity of eggs."

"You made eggs for a jury."

That got a real laugh out of her, and Maya looked quietly pleased with herself.

The video, as Simone understood it from briefings she had not requested, was fifty-eight seconds long. Somebody on the second floor had filmed the part that mattered to the internet. Officer Hayes asking his questions. Elena Ruiz with her hands folded, saying what she had said. Simone's own voice, calm enough to be subtitled without difficulty, saying that she would not open her bag, and then, later, saying the sentence that had apparently been clipped, quoted, printed and reprinted until it belonged to everyone: that she had not been protecting a store, she had been protecting an assumption, and that being innocent should have been enough.

By nine o'clock there was a second number, and by ten a third. One million. One million four hundred thousand. Maya stopped announcing them, which Simone understood to mean they had become too large to be funny.

"People keep asking me if it is you," Maya said, from the doorway, with her phone in her hand and her shoes already on. "Like, at school. Girls I barely know. A teacher."

"What do you tell them?"

"That my mother can, in fact, shop."

"Good answer."

"One of them asked if you were going to sue the store." Maya hesitated, and the hesitation was new. "Are you?"

"No."

"Are you going to sue her?"

"No."

"Are you going to do anything?"

Simone considered the question with the seriousness it deserved, because her daughter was not asking about litigation. She was asking whether the machinery Maya had grown up watching, the office, the title, the fifteen-minute calendar and the secure phone and the staff who called her mother Doctor Bennett in the tone of people defusing something, whether all of that was now going to turn, slowly and terribly, toward a woman in a department store.

"I am going to take you to get your hair done at two," Simone said, "because you have an appointment and because Tuesday is picture day. That is the extent of my plans for Caroline Whitmore."

"You know her name now."

"Everyone knows her name now. That is part of the problem."

That was the part Simone could not stop turning over. By nine thirty, people Simone had never met had found Caroline's name, her husband's name, the name of his company, the street the Whitmores lived on, the clubs she belonged to, and the email address of a charity she chaired. By ten, there were messages Simone was shown by a friend in the attorney general's office, who sent them with the word "FYI" and a grimace audible through the text. Wishes for ruin. Wishes for worse than ruin. A photograph of the Whitmore house with the address legible. Someone had written that they hoped she never slept soundly again, and someone else, more efficient, had simply posted a telephone number.

News in the same category

Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

30 Part