Three garments in. She had watched them go in herself, following at a distance she had told herself was browsing, counting as she counted place settings at a fundraiser, automatically and with total certainty. The blue dress. The burgundy gown. The white blouse.
Two garments out.
The blue dress, over one arm. The white blouse. And a suit, which Caroline discounted entirely, because suits were not what she had been watching. Of the burgundy gown, there was no sign at all.
Caroline felt something she would later be ashamed to have called satisfaction, and at the time called clarity. She had been right in the first minute, and now the arithmetic stood in front of the whole floor: three in, two out.
It did not occur to her to ask the fitting-room attendant. She went to the manager, because managers were the machinery by which concerns like hers became outcomes.
Elena Ruiz ran the designer floor with the unadvertised authority of a woman who has dressed senators' wives and rock musicians in the same week. She was reviewing a return when Caroline arrived.
"Ms. Ruiz. I need you to stop a woman before she leaves this floor."
Elena looked up. "Mrs. Whitmore. Stop a woman from doing what?"
"From leaving with a burgundy evening gown she did not pay for. She went into your fitting rooms with three garments and came out with two. I watched her myself. The gown is in her bag, or under that suit, and your associate refused to take it seriously."
Elena set the return down slowly. "Which customer are we discussing?"
"The tall woman. At the register now, with Jasmine."
"Dr. Bennett is a customer of this store, Mrs. Whitmore."
"Then she will not mind being asked to open her bag. Two minutes, and if I am wrong I will apologize in front of whoever you like." Caroline kept her voice even. She was not a hysterical woman; hysterical women were ignored. "I counted, Elena. Three in. Two out. I am reporting."
"What you are reporting is arithmetic. Arithmetic is not evidence." Elena came around the desk, not quickly. "I will not have a customer searched on a count taken from across a sales floor. Nothing has been reported missing by anyone whose job it is to know."
"Her bag, then. Ask her to open it at the door, politely. Stores do it every day."
"This store does not, on suspicion alone, and I make that decision on this floor." Elena held her gaze. "And do not approach Dr. Bennett yourself. If you believe a crime has occurred, you know the avenue for that. It is not ambush at a register."
"You are refusing," Caroline said.
"I am declining to search a customer because you counted her clothing. Yes."
"Then I will have to handle it another way."
"Mrs. Whitmore." Elena's voice dropped, and in it was something older than professional courtesy: warning. "Think about what another way means, before you choose it."
Caroline had already chosen it, in the handbag department, and every step since had only been the paperwork. She took out her phone and dialed the three numbers she had dialed perhaps twice in her life.
"Nine one one," she said, clearly. "I am at Bellmont and Avery, downtown, second floor. I need police. I have witnessed a theft in progress."
Simone was at the register with Jasmine when the officers came up the escalator, not in a hurry, which told her more about the call they had answered than anything they might say.
Two of them. Daniel Hayes, late thirties, tall, a man who had learned that most emergencies shrink if approached at walking pace. His partner, Tom Beckett, younger, stayed a half step back, watching the room.
Jasmine had the blue dress folded in tissue when they arrived, the suit beside it, the tie in its box. Her hands kept moving, out of training, while her eyes went from the officers to Simone and back.
"Dr. Bennett?" Hayes said.
"Yes."
"Ma'am, we have had a report concerning merchandise and your shopping bag. I need to ask you a few questions, here, if you are willing."
Around them, the floor performed the small, terrible choreography of public trouble. Someone near the escalators lifted a phone. Simone registered the phones as facts.
"Ask," she said.
Caroline arrived at the pace of a woman joining a meeting she had called, which she had.
"Officers, thank you. I am the person who called. I watched this woman take three garments into the fitting rooms and come out with two. The missing one is a burgundy gown, very valuable. The manager refused to check her bag. I would like it checked now."
"Ma'am," Hayes said, "let me work through it in order. Dr. Bennett, did you take three garments into the fitting room?"