had highlighted, in a memorandum his director had not answered, in the
yellow of a man crying out in the only colour available to him: the
growth was not in police-ordered tows at all. It was in a category
Hawkeye's quarterly returns called association assists, reported to the
city, year upon year, in the firm's own summaries, in plain figures, in
documents the city had received, filed, and - this was the sentence in
Doyle's second memorandum, which had also gone unanswered, and
which Sloane read aloud at the council's special session in May in a voice
that made the chamber's air conditioning audible - "accepted as evidence
of a thriving contractor."
The contract had been renewed in January, for three years, on the
recommendation of the director of public services, Neil Corrigan, under
the auto-renewal clause that spared the city a competitive process where a
contractor's performance was rated satisfactory, and Corrigan, giving his
account to the council and, on the following day, under oath, to Beckett,
did not dissemble, which the investigators noted, and did not excuse
himself, which they noted also. He had rated Hawkeye satisfactory. He
had done so on the basis of the firm's own summaries, a complaints file
that was empty - because, as the session established in a silence that
lasted eleven seconds by the clerk's recording, complaints about
association tows had been routed by the city's own switchboard, for
years, to the code office, whose log was not the public services
department's log, so that the department that renewed the contract had
never seen the only paper in the building that described the contractor's
conduct - and on the basis, Corrigan said at last, looking down the table
at Kevin Doyle as a man looks at a lifeboat he declined to board, of the
rising numbers themselves, which he had read, as rising numbers in a
quarterly return are read by every busy director in every city hall in
America, as success. "Who at city hall renewed Hawkeye without asking
why its numbers kept rising?" Colin Ashe wrote in the Gazette, and the
answer, when the council's session had finished printing it in the minutes,
was the answer nobody in the chamber could resign from, because it was
everybody's and therefore, for a dangerous week, nobody's: the system
had renewed Hawkeye. The system had received the figures, and filed the
complaints in another building, and rated the whole arrangement
satisfactory in January, three months before a yellow car went up on a
hook and brought the filing system, the complaints log and the
satisfactory rating into the same room at last, with a seal in a photograph,
bending its river the wrong way, to introduce them to each other. The
council voted, that night, to suspend Hawkeye Recovery from the
municipal rotation pending the county's proceedings, to commission an
outside review of the towing ordinance and of Code 8.32 itself - whose
final sentence, quoted in the chamber by a council member who had
plainly read it for the first time that evening, about delegating the
authority of the city to any private association, company or person, was
ordered printed in the review's terms of reference - and to write to the
county attorney, formally, what Hallow Bend had been saying in its
kitchens for a fortnight: that the city requested the fullest examination, of
its own house included, and would keep its hands, this time, where
everyone could see them.
And Adrian, through all of it, was where his memorandum had put
him, which was in the one place a chief of police is never trained to be: in
the file, as a paragraph, being read by other people. The examination of
his own conduct proceeded in the same conference room, by the same
two investigators, in the same week as the money, and it proceeded, as he
had asked, without deference and without theatre. Whitlock was
interviewed for three hours about eleven minutes. She was asked why a
supervisor had attended a tow dispute, and answered that supervisors
attended disputed seizures of property in her department as a matter of
course, and that she would invite the investigators to pull the year's CAD
records and count the occasions on which she had attended for residents
whose names she had never known and whose jobs she had never
wondered about; they did, and the count was forty-one, and the Sycamore
Hollow attendance sat among them in every particular of timing and rank
like a stone among stones. She was asked what the protected flag had
bought, and answered that it had bought the owner exactly one thing,
which was that his name had not been spoken on a recorded channel by
the people paid to protect it, and that this privacy was the flag's entire
purpose, extended by policy to judges, shelter directors and witnesses
who were not chiefs of anything, and that if the investigators were asking
whether it had bought him the set-down, they should look at the
notebook, the photographs, and the driver's own statement, in which the
paper failed on its face for any owner in the county. Renee Osei was
interviewed for an hour about ninety seconds, and emerged with her
practice vindicated in terms she received with a dispatcher's economy:
she had routed by the screen, kept the name off the air, and sent the