Ruby's sister Alice had disappeared on the night of the pavilion fire. No body had ever been found. Everyone assumed she'd gone into the water behind the building. Someone had seen her standing on the jetty after the smoke alarm, wearing a silver coat from the costume room.
“The police closed the search after four days,” Ruby said.
“Is she alive?”
“Last I knew. We haven't spoken in eight years.”
They had hidden Alice because her husband had followed her to three different addresses. He'd arrived on Mercy Island with an order giving him temporary custody of their son. He'd also arrived with two broken fingers on his right hand. Ruby had broken them with a frying pan a month earlier. Nobody would have described the sisters as a family inclined to let a man finish what he'd started.
“What was the boy's name?”
“Thomas.”
There was no Thomas among the twenty-nine stars. I remembered because my own middle name was Thomasina, and I'd been looking for any variation.
“Where did he go?”
Ruby closed her eyes.
“That's the question,” June said. “That's the bit none of you ever told me.”
***
The Paid Fare
On the drive home Kit called to say that someone had paid a penny into the seawall appeal.
“Fair enough,” I said. “Every little helps.”
“There's a message. It says that admits me, provided I bring a responsible child.”
I pulled over beside a field of black cattle and watched them investigate a feed bucket. “Is there a name?”
“An invoice number. Whoever did it wants a receipt.”
The payment came from a landscape business in Oregon. Its owner, a man named Thomas Price, agreed to speak on the condition that neither his voice nor his picture appeared online. He could take the call on Monday.
I told him about the board meeting.
“I'll call before that,” he said.
His voice was mild and a little nasal. He sounded like the man who came once a year to check my boiler. I'd been hoping, I realized, for a dramatic man with a dramatic voice, somebody you could listen to for five seconds and think, Well, naturally all those lives had to change for him.
Instead I heard a child ask him to fix a zipper. “Coming, love,” Thomas said. Then he hung up on me.
***
What the Water Kept
Back in the workshop the horse lay on its side. Elaine had found a dark line of salt crystals beneath its belly. To leave that mark the animal must have stood for hours in water up to the middle of its chest.
“The flood came after the fire,” she said. “Look here.”
In a split in the wood, ash lay beneath salt. Soot first, water later. The old newspaper accounts all described a fire started by a short circuit in a flooded room. Somebody had got the order wrong.
“If the tide was still low,” I said, “you could walk off the jetty.”
“You could certainly try. Can you swim?”
“Only when sufficiently frightened.”
We got the tide tables from a retired harbor pilot. The night Alice vanished wasn't a night of spring tides. On the contrary, the water had been unusually low. On his chart, a pale dotted line led from the jetty to a small brick building on the mainland.
“What was that?” I asked him.
“Town mortuary.”
I looked at Elaine.
The old man snorted. “Before you two get yourselves worked up, it was the icehouse first. Around here everything has had at least two jobs.”
***
A Pocketful of Buttons
Dora admitted she had walked the causeway that night. She had carried five children, one after another, over the deepest channel. Her skirt pockets had filled with water. A little boy had given her a button each time she came back for another child.
“I've still got them.”
She produced four green buttons and a coin.
“He ran out of buttons. I didn't see him again until my own wedding. He served the fish. Kept his thumb out of the sauce, too. I felt we'd both done quite well.”
I asked why she had made the children cross the mud when there was a perfectly good road.
“Alice's husband was on the road. He had two friends with him. I had no idea whether any of the three could tell one small boy from another.”
“So you moved them all?”
“We gave a performance. There were thirty children in costume that night. Twenty-nine came out in their own clothes.”
“And Thomas?”
“Thomas came out in mine.”
She smiled at my expression. The boy had been fifteen, she said, already an inch taller than Dora. Everyone who came looking for a little child had walked straight past him.
***
The Unfinished Hem
Dora's dress had a deep hem with one section still basted in yellow thread. She had meant to finish it thirty years ago but Thomas had taken it with him. It had come back in a parcel the previous autumn. There was no return address. Just a note saying that on some islands a woman could grow thirty years older without ever getting her best dress back.