“I've still got them.”
She produced four green buttons and a coin.
“He ran out of buttons. I didn't see him again until my own wedding. He served the fish. Kept his thumb out of the sauce, too. I felt we'd both done quite well.”
I asked why she had made the children cross the mud when there was a perfectly good road.
“Alice's husband was on the road. He had two friends with him. I had no idea whether any of the three could tell one small boy from another.”
“So you moved them all?”
“We gave a performance. There were thirty children in costume that night. Twenty-nine came out in their own clothes.”
“And Thomas?”
“Thomas came out in mine.”
She smiled at my expression. The boy had been fifteen, she said, already an inch taller than Dora. Everyone who came looking for a little child had walked straight past him.
***
The Unfinished Hem
Dora's dress had a deep hem with one section still basted in yellow thread. She had meant to finish it thirty years ago but Thomas had taken it with him. It had come back in a parcel the previous autumn. There was no return address. Just a note saying that on some islands a woman could grow thirty years older without ever getting her best dress back.
“Did his mother go with him?”
“I believed so.”
“But you don't anymore.”
“I'm eighty. I no longer believe shampoo will improve my hair. Be precise about what you want to know.”
I asked who had given the alarm and what Frankie had meant by closing a door.
“The alarm was a dinner gong. Nell, there wasn't a fire alarm. We could barely afford eggs.”
It was the first time she had said my name without caution. I let the moment go past. She smoothed the yellow thread with her thumb.
“Frankie closed the scenery store. There was a person inside. I thought he deserved it. That wasn't the proudest moment of my life.”
“What was?”
“Opening it again, I suppose.”
***
A Little Salt
On Saturday morning my neighbor brought me a jar of marmalade. I offered her tea. She stayed long enough to tell me that, in her opinion, I was trying to get a dead woman to apologize for leaving me.
“Do you have any friends who like you less than I do?” she asked.
“I don't think so.”
“Good. Somebody should tell you when you're being ridiculous. You know perfectly well what your mother was like.”
I did. Frankie had once forgotten to collect me from school because she'd seen a man selling secondhand fishing rods and remembered, quite suddenly, that she wanted to go fishing. She had nevertheless taught herself to cut my hair around a hearing aid I wore for six difficult months. She had left sweet notes in my lunchbox and forgotten to include the lunch.
I opened the marmalade. There was a little salt in it, just enough to bring out the sweetness.
“Did you do that on purpose?”
My neighbor peered at the label. “Oh, for heaven's sake. That's glaze for a ham.”
We ate it on toast anyway. For half an hour I let the dead look after themselves.
***
Thomas in the Greenhouse
Thomas called from a greenhouse. Rain struck its roof so hard I could occasionally see his lips move without hearing what he said. He held up a handwritten sign. CAN YOU HEAR ME? I held up one of my own. MOSTLY RAIN.
He took me into a potting shed. “I'm not very good at drama,” he said. “You're expecting a man who's going to tell you his old man hurt him.”
“Did he?”
“Sometimes. Mostly he hurt my mother where I had to see. He understood the value of an audience.”
His father had found them at the pavilion because Thomas had written to his grandmother. A boy of fifteen could be old enough to remember an address and young enough to think his grandmother would keep a secret.
“You didn't cause what happened.”
“That's kind of you. But I'm a gardener. If I plant something I don't say the rain planted it just because the rain came along.”
He had taken Dora's dress and walked out with the last of the kitchen staff. Outside the icehouse his aunt Ruby was waiting with a car. He had never seen Alice on the jetty in a silver coat. He had seen her somewhere else, hours later, sitting in the front seat of a police cruiser.
***
The Arrest Nobody Made
The deputy in that cruiser had been Kit's grandfather, Peter Alden. His son had found his old notebooks after he died and donated them to the historical society. They weren't secret. They weren't particularly interesting either, unless you wanted to know what brand of beer people stole most frequently on Mercy Island in 1994.
At midnight on the night of the fire Peter had written one entry. Transported woman to St Agnes. No charge.