The sender's name was Thomas Price.
He'd kept the other piece in his wallet since the night they took the car from the icehouse. Frankie had torn off the corner and given it to him as proof that the rest would stay hidden until he was ready. She had shown him where she hid it beneath the silver.
“You don't have to tell us,” I said.
“I wish people would stop offering me the opportunity to remain fifteen.”
He asked for a day. He wanted to speak to his daughter first. I had imagined the child with the broken zipper was four or five. She was twenty, he said. The zipper belonged to her wedding dress, and she was trying to see how much her father could repair before she had to pay an actual dressmaker.
“How much could you repair?”
“Ask me about the island. Spare me the humiliation of the dress.”
***
A Ferry Without Water
The next afternoon Kit drove me to the mainland icehouse. There were two ways into the old building. The front was blocked by blocks of new concrete. The side was a plain door leading into a snug exhibition about local birdlife.
Inside, an electric heater made orange stripes on the floor. A volunteer apologized because the puffin was away having its beak reglued.
We asked if we might see the basement. She showed us a trapdoor and a steep set of steps. The floor was made of boards cut from an old ferry deck. Cleats still projected from the walls.
“I always thought the icehouse was on land,” Kit said.
“It is now. They filled in the slip in ninety-six.”
In 1994 a boat could have come into that room while the tide was out in front of the pavilion. The deep channel ran around the far side.
Behind the steps someone had painted a pencil mark silver to preserve it. It was the height of a little girl. Beside it was a date, exactly one year after the disappearance.
Frankie had come back to the island with me. Whatever else she had done, she hadn't been running all those years.
***
The Boy with the Key
Thomas called after dinner. June and I put him on speaker. We'd ordered a pizza. I had taken the olives off my half and discovered a small pile of them on the edge of hers, too.
“I locked him in,” Thomas said. “He shoved Mum against the cabinet. I got between them. She fell and he went to pick her up. I thought he was going to hit her again. I pulled him backward and Frankie got Mum away. Then I shut the door.”
“Frankie said she shut it.”
“She put her hands on mine. We both did. I turned the key. The lights went out and all that lovely brave feeling left me at once.”
On the other side of the showroom the fire had reached the carpet. Alice put it out. Then she went back to unlock the store. The key wouldn't turn. The wood around the lock had swollen.
“I stood there hoping she wouldn't get it open.”
“What happened to him?”
“He climbed through the far window. We spent all that time trying to get a door open for an empty room.”
He began to laugh, quite softly at first. His daughter came and put her arms around him. A little row of crooked stitches showed against the white cloth on her shoulder.
***
The Difference a Door Makes
Thomas's father had died two summers ago. He had married again. There was another daughter, grown now, who remembered a man who could cut an apple into the shape of a swan.
“Is that why my mother never explained?” I asked Ruby. “To protect his reputation?”
“She was protecting a boy who thought he'd once hoped hard enough to kill a person. She believed that feeling belonged to him. He could talk about it when he wanted to.”
It was a handsome answer and I was tired of handsome answers.
“Then why couldn't I have known June? What secret would giving me a sister have broken?”
Ruby stood at my sink with a cup in her hand. It had been hot when she picked it up. When she finally put it down the tea was cold.
“We quarreled,” she said.
“About what?”
“About whether we could keep living together after all that. Your mum thought I should have gone to the police sooner. I thought she was always going to blame me for my sister getting hurt. We were twenty-seven, Nell. We made an enormous mistake and then we worked very hard for thirty years at pretending it was an adult decision.”
***
A Chair for Alice
Alice agreed to meet us at a hotel near the train station. I recognized her from the photograph's family resemblance, although she had Ruby's eyes and none of Ruby's talent for standing still. She straightened three menus and changed chairs twice before her tea came.