“Is that why my mother never explained?” I asked Ruby. “To protect his reputation?”
“She was protecting a boy who thought he'd once hoped hard enough to kill a person. She believed that feeling belonged to him. He could talk about it when he wanted to.”
It was a handsome answer and I was tired of handsome answers.
“Then why couldn't I have known June? What secret would giving me a sister have broken?”
Ruby stood at my sink with a cup in her hand. It had been hot when she picked it up. When she finally put it down the tea was cold.
“We quarreled,” she said.
“About what?”
“About whether we could keep living together after all that. Your mum thought I should have gone to the police sooner. I thought she was always going to blame me for my sister getting hurt. We were twenty-seven, Nell. We made an enormous mistake and then we worked very hard for thirty years at pretending it was an adult decision.”
***
A Chair for Alice
Alice agreed to meet us at a hotel near the train station. I recognized her from the photograph's family resemblance, although she had Ruby's eyes and none of Ruby's talent for standing still. She straightened three menus and changed chairs twice before her tea came.
The reunion had already taken place in private, by telephone. Thomas and his mother had spent four hours discussing absolutely everything except the fire. He wanted to know where she'd learned to make dumplings. She wanted to know what had become of his clarinet.
I asked whether her husband had ever found her again.
“He didn't try. That's what was so terrible. I paid for safety for thirty years and some of that safety I might have had for nothing.”
She took milk. June passed her an entire little jug and she emptied it.
“Some of it,” she repeated. “I'm not going to sit here and let anybody say that woman should simply have stayed in her kitchen and hoped her husband grew nicer.”
She wanted one thing at the reunion. Would there be another performance? She had missed her cue the first time and had kept her costume for thirty-two years.
***
Dress Rehearsal
The silver coat arrived in a garment bag from a dry cleaner in Tulsa. Across the shoulders and down one arm ran a streak of black. Alice had never tried to get it out.
We put the coat on a stand beside the horse. Where the sleeve brushed its flank, a few flecks of silver came away. Under the silver it was painted an almost violent blue.
Susie groaned. “That blue. I scrubbed that off children for a week.”
The horse hadn't been silver at the performance. The cast had painted it the next morning, after almost everybody had gone. We had assumed Frankie had hidden her letter on the night of the fire. But she couldn't have had time to write it, collect the envelope, paste it to a horse and cover it with two coats of paint.
“Does it matter?” Kit asked.
It mattered to me. Frankie hadn't left a terrified confession in the middle of a crisis. She'd made breakfast. She'd picked the clothes she was going to put on. She'd looked at my three-year-old face and decided that one day I ought to know.
For the first time I could imagine a future beyond finding out what happened. My mother, apparently, had been able to imagine it all along.
***
A Performance in Pieces
We found twenty-four of the original players. Of the others, three had died, two had moved away leaving no forwarding addresses, and one sent a postcard saying that the happiest part of his childhood was the fact that it was over. He enclosed a dollar for the wall.
Nobody had the script. A woman in Michigan remembered being told to enter wearing a fish on her head. A man in Georgia recalled a joke about a sleeping judge that he'd never been able to make funny since. Susie had kept the menu. On the back, in the square handwriting of a practical girl, someone had written WHAT HAPPENS AFTER THE SEA STEALS THE TOWN?
Beneath it another child had written THEY BUILD A BOAT OUT OF THE TOWN.
That was the play.
Kit laid thirty slips of paper on his kitchen table, each bearing a thing ordinarily found in a town. The children had turned a butcher's counter into a ship's prow. A bedstead had become a rudder. The judge's wig had become a mop.
Sid picked up the slip that said SCHOOL BELL.
“That's easy,” he said. “When you're lost in the fog you ring it so the other boats know somebody's there.”
***
A Different Kind of Sale