"You told everyone it was a supplement," she said. "A supplement. Do you know what a supplement is, Danielle? A vitamin. A powder you stir into a smoothie because you read about it in a magazine. You stood in front of thirty people and called it a supplement while your son held up his phone."
"I never meant to hurt him," I said.
"You never mean anything," Margaret said. "That is the problem with you. You never mean it, and it keeps happening anyway."
She left then, without waiting for Marcus to come downstairs, without waiting for me to answer her. The front door closed behind her, and the house went quiet, and Denise stayed at the table with her hands around her mug, and neither of us spoke for a long time.
"Is it true?" Denise asked at last. "All of it?"
I thought about the fourteen years of money. I thought about Thomas. I thought about the packet in my dress pocket and the spoon in the glass. I thought about the insurance, which I had said at the party because it was the first thing that came into my head when Marcus asked me what I was trying to do to him, and how small and stupid that word sounded now.
"Most of it," I said.
Denise nodded slowly, as if she had expected that answer and had been afraid of it in equal measure.
"I am still your sister," she said. "But I cannot lie for you anymore. I want you to know that before anything else happens."
"I know," I said.
She left a little while later, and I stayed in the kitchen, and I understood something I had not understood at the party. At the party, I had thought the worst thing was being caught. Now I understood that the worst thing was what came after being caught, which was everyone I loved taking turns telling me, out loud, what I had done, while I stood there and listened, because there was nothing left to say that would make any of it untrue.
Chapter 20: Twelve Thousand Dollars
Marcus came downstairs that evening with a bank statement in his hand. He laid it on the kitchen table between us, smoothed it flat with his palm the way he does when he is trying very hard not to raise his voice, and pointed at a line halfway down the page.
"Twelve thousand dollars," he said. "To Margaret. Tell me about it."
I looked at the line. It was there in black and white, a transfer I had made months ago, one of so many that I had stopped counting them a long time before. Twelve thousand dollars, from our joint account to Margaret Reed. The statement printed it plainly, $12,000, with a date beside it, and seeing the number in print, in that cold bank typeface, made it feel more real than any of the other transfers had ever felt. The others had been numbers in my head, numbers I could blur and soften and pretend were smaller than they were. This one was on paper, in Marcus's hand, and there was no blurring it.
I remembered the day I sent it. Margaret had called me in the late afternoon, her voice low, asking if I could help, just this once, just quietly, because Jordan needed new shoes for school and there was a doctor's bill she had not expected, and she did not want Raymond to know she was short. I had said yes before she finished the sentence, because saying yes was what I did, because the money was there and no one was watching, because helping felt like the one good thing I could still do with money that was not really mine to give. I had sent it that same evening, from my phone, sitting on the edge of our bed while Marcus was downstairs watching television, and I had deleted the confirmation message the moment it arrived.
"It was for Jordan," I said. "School fees. Medical bills. Margaret asked me quietly, and I sent it, because it was easier than saying no, and because the money was there, and because no one was watching."
"School fees," Marcus said. "Jordan's school fees. Paid to his aunt, not to the school."
"Margaret said she would handle it," I said. "She said the school preferred it that way, and the doctor's office too, and I believed her, or I wanted to believe her, because believing her meant I did not have to think about it."
Marcus stared at me. "Did she know?" he asked. "Did Margaret know about the money? About what you were doing?"
"I don't know," I said, and it was the truth. "She never said so. She asked for twelve thousand dollars, and I sent it, and she never asked where it came from, and I never told her. Maybe she knew. Maybe she didn't want to know. People are very good at not knowing things when knowing them would cost them something."