"I took Patricia's money," Raymond said. "I signed your name. I helped Marcus bury Elliot Marsh, and I have carried it for twenty years, and I am telling you now because I am tired of carrying it, and because if Marcus keeps digging, it will come out anyway, and I would rather it came out from me."
Marcus stood up then, slowly, as if his body had forgotten how to do it. He looked at his brother, and his face was white, and I saw something in his eyes that I had never seen there before, not even at the party, not even when Jordan held up his phone.
"Where is he?" Marcus asked. "Where is Elliot now?"
Raymond hesitated. Then he told us. He told us the address, and the building, and the door, and I wrote it down on the back of a receipt I found in my purse, because my hands were shaking and I needed something to do with them.
"Go and see him," Raymond said. "Both of you. Go and see what we did to him. And then decide what kind of family this is."
We left his study without another word. In the car, Marcus did not speak. I did not speak. We drove home through streets I had driven a thousand times, and everything looked the same, and nothing was the same, because I had just learned that my husband, the man I had lied to for fourteen years, had done something far worse than lying, and that his own brother had helped him do it, and that the man they had erased had been living somewhere in this city for twenty years, waiting.
Chapter 24: The Pale Blue Door
The next morning, I drove to the address on the back of the receipt.
It was not a good neighborhood, and it was not a bad one. It was the kind of neighborhood where the buildings are old and the paint is peeling and the people who live there have learned not to ask each other too many questions. I parked across the street and sat in the car for a long time, looking at the building, trying to decide whether to go in.
The building was older than the ones around it, brick gone dark with age, windows with curtains pulled half shut, a row of mailboxes by the front door with names I did not recognize. A woman came out with a bag of groceries and did not look at me. A man in a work jacket went in with a toolbox and held the door for no one. It was the kind of building where people mind their own business, and I thought about how well that must have suited Elliot, a man who had spent twenty years learning not to be noticed. I thought about the library where he worked, about the shelves and the quiet, about a man who had once stood beside my husband at the front of a company and now shelved books for strangers. I sat in the car until my hands stopped shaking, and then I got out, and I crossed the street, and I went in, because I had come all this way, and because turning back would have been one more cowardly thing in a life that already had too many of them.
The receipt said the third floor. It said the door was pale blue. I had not believed Raymond when he told us, not entirely, because the story of Elliot Marsh had been over for twenty years, and dead men do not live in apartments with pale blue doors. But I went anyway, because I needed to know, and because Marcus had not come with me, and because someone in this family had to look at what we had done.
I climbed the stairs slowly. The hallway smelled of cooking and damp, and the light was the kind of yellow light that makes everything look older than it is. On the third floor, at the end of the hall, there was a door painted pale blue, the paint chipped at the edges, and I stood in front of it for a long time with my hand raised, not knocking, because once I knocked, whatever was behind that door would be real.
I knocked.
Nothing happened. I knocked again, harder, and I heard movement inside, slow footsteps, and then the door opened, and a man stood there looking at me, and I knew at once that it was him, even though he was nothing like the photographs I remembered.
He was thinner than Marcus. His hair was grey at the temples, and his face was lined in a way that made him look older than his years, and his clothes were clean but worn, the clothes of a man who buys what he needs and nothing more. But his eyes were the same. I remembered those eyes from twenty years ago, from the wedding photographs, from the company picnics, from the days when he and Marcus had been inseparable, and I knew them now, in a hallway that smelled of cooking and damp, on a morning I had not planned for.
"Are you Elliot Marsh?" I asked.