"I went to see Elliot," I said.
"I know," he said.
"We need to talk," I said. "Not about me. Not about the money. Not about Thomas. About Elliot. About what you did to him. About what we are going to do now."
He nodded, slowly, and he sat down at the table, and I sat across from him, and the house went quiet around us, and I knew that whatever came next, it would not be easy, and it would not be quick, and it would not make any of it untrue. But it would be the truth, finally, out in the open, between us, and that was more than either of us had managed in twenty years.
Chapter 28: The Evidence Hidden for Twenty Years
Marcus brought him home the next morning. He did not call first. He did not warn me. I was in the kitchen with a mug of coffee gone cold in my hands when I heard the front door open, and then Marcus's voice in the hallway, low and careful, and another man's voice answering him, quieter still. I stood there for a moment with the mug against my palms, listening, and then I walked into the living room, and there he was.
Elliot Marsh was sitting on our sofa. He was forty-eight years old, and he looked older than that, the way a man looks when he has spent years trying not to be seen. His coat was thin and worn at the cuffs. His shoes were clean but old. He had a canvas bag on his lap, and both of his hands rested on it, the way a man holds something he is afraid someone will take from him. He stood up when he saw me. He was taller than I remembered from the photographs Marcus kept in his study, and thinner, and his hair had gone grey at the temples, but his eyes were the same. I had seen those eyes in a dozen photographs on the wall of the office Marcus and Elliot had built together, back when Jordan was only a baby and the company was new and everything in our lives still felt possible.
"Danielle," Marcus said. He was standing by the fireplace, and he did not look at me. He looked at Elliot. "This is Elliot. Elliot Marsh."
"I know who he is," I said. My voice sounded strange to me, too steady, too calm. "Hello, Elliot."
"Hello, Danielle," he said. "Thank you for letting me into your house."
I did not answer that. I sat down in the chair across from the sofa, and I folded my hands in my lap, and I waited. Marcus stayed by the fireplace, his arms crossed, his jaw set the way it gets when he is holding himself together by force. For a long time nobody said anything. The clock on the mantel ticked. A car went past outside. Elliot opened the canvas bag.
He took out a notebook first. It was a plain black notebook, the kind you buy in any office supply store, and the cover was scuffed and soft at the corners from twenty years of being carried and hidden and carried again. He set it on the coffee table between us. Then he took out a bank statement, folded twice, the paper yellowed at the edges, and he set that down beside the notebook. Then he took out a second statement, and a third, and he laid them out in a row, one after another, his hands steady, his movements careful, like a man laying out evidence in a courtroom he had built in his head a thousand times.
"Twenty years," he said. "I kept everything for twenty years. Every page. Every number. I did not know if anyone would ever look at them. I kept them anyway."
Marcus did not move. He stared at the papers on the coffee table, and I watched his face, and I saw something I had never seen on it before. Not anger. Not fear. Something smaller and worse than either of those. Recognition.
"I did not steal the money," Elliot said. His voice was level. He was not shouting. He had waited twenty years to say this, and he did not need to shout it. "Marcus did."
The words sat in the room like a stone dropped into still water. I looked at Marcus, and Marcus looked at the papers, and Elliot sat with his hands folded on his lap again, waiting, patient as a man who has already waited half his life.
"Show me," Marcus said at last. His voice was rough. "Show me what you have."
Elliot leaned forward and opened the notebook. The pages were filled with his handwriting, small and neat, columns of numbers and dates, and beside the numbers, in the margin, notes in the same hand. He turned the pages slowly, and he pointed to the entries with one finger, and he read them out in a voice that never rose.
"This one," he said. "Six thousand eight hundred dollars. Moved from the company account into a personal account. The signature on the transfer is mine. I never signed it." He turned a page. "This one. Eighteen thousand dollars. Same account. Same signature. Not mine." He turned another page. "Seven thousand two hundred dollars. Same."