So the questions went where everything went now: to Susan Park, my attorney, who had become the narrow bridge across which my entire former life was conducted. Susan was fifty-two, unhurried, and entirely without illusions, and she had set the rules in her office the first day: "You will want to talk to her. Every client in your position wants to talk to her. You will not. You will not call, you will not text, you will not drive past the house in Brentwood, you will not ask her sister how she is, you will not send messages through the children — and Andrew, listen to me, because this is the part clients get wrong: you will not respond if she reaches out to you. If she calls, you hang up and call me. If she writes, you don't read it, you forward it to me. Contact is the one gift you could hand her defense that they cannot manufacture on their own. Her lawyers would love nothing more than a grieving, angry husband who couldn't stay away. We give them nothing. Do you understand?"
"I understand," I said. "I don't like it, but I understand."
"You don't have to like it. You have to do it. Liking it is not in the retainer."
It was through Susan, then, that the last exchanges of my marriage were conducted, and they were not exchanges at all, they were transmissions between lawyers, printed on letterhead. Lauren's attorney wrote to request the return of certain personal items from the house — clothing, a jewelry box that had been her grandmother's, photographs of her parents. Susan sent me the list to review, and I sat at the kitchen table — that table, where everything had happened — and I checked off boxes about my wife's sweaters like a man approving a shipping manifest, and I wrote, in the margin, in pencil, "the blue coat too, it's hers, she'll be cold," and then I erased it, because Susan had told me to communicate facts and nothing else, and because I did not know what to do with the discovery that some reflex in me was still dressing her for the weather. Her lawyer wrote to propose that she be allowed a phone call with Grace, supervised. Susan called me about it and was honest: the court would likely allow some contact between Lauren and her daughter eventually, through channels, with supervision, and fighting the first supervised call entirely might cost me credibility I would need later. I said yes to one call, fifteen minutes, with the counselor on the line, because Grace had begun asking questions I couldn't answer, and because refusing felt like using my daughter as a wall, and I would not do that either. I stood in the hallway outside Grace's room during that call and I listened to my daughter's voice go bright and small through the door — "Hi, Mommy" — and I put my forehead against the wall and I did not go in, and I did not listen for Lauren's voice through the wood, and it cost me something I don't have a word for. It cost me something every day. Restraint isn't a single act. It's a subscription. It renews every morning.
There were nights I sat in my truck in the driveway with my phone in my hand and her number on the screen — not her old number, she'd gotten a new one through the bail arrangements, and it had come to me on a court document, which is a hell of a way to receive your wife's phone number — and I would sit there composing the one question I'd ask if I could ask only one. I never pressed call. I want that on whatever record this is. I never pressed call. I deleted the drafts of texts I never sent, dozens of them, and some of them were rage and some of them were worse than rage, some of them were please. A man can hold a phone like a weapon and a lifeline at the same time. Every night I put it down, and every night that was the bravest and the loneliest thing I did, and nobody will ever give me credit for it, and that's fine. That's what it's for.
Grace asked me on a Sunday evening, three weeks and a day after the party. I knew it was coming. For three weeks she had been moving around the edges of the question the way she used to move around the deep end of a pool, a toe at a time. She had asked where Mom was, in the first days, and I had told her Mom was staying with Aunt Claire and that there were grown-up problems being worked out, and she had accepted that with the terrible, trusting acceptance of a twelve-year-old who believes her father is a load-bearing wall. But she was twelve, not six. She had a phone. She had friends whose mothers had opinions and internet connections. She had watched police cars in our driveway and her mother's name move across the bottom of a television screen in a restaurant before Paul could get the waiter to change the channel. The toe-testing had to end. I had rehearsed for it the way I rehearsed for Beckett and Susan and Priya, which is to say constantly and without ever feeling ready.
She came into the kitchen while I was making dinner — spaghetti, the one meal I could produce without supervision — and she stood by the counter with her hands twisted in the hem of her shirt, and she said, "Dad. I need you to tell me the real thing. Not the little-kid thing. The real thing."