The holidays came at us the way holidays do, with their own momentum, and I will not pretend I didn't dread them. Thanksgiving first: Paul drove in with a turkey he insisted on frying in my driveway in a rig that looked like it could launch something into orbit, and Priya's husband stood at a respectful distance holding a fire extinguisher he had brought from home, just in case, and Grace laughed so hard at the two of them that she had to sit down on the porch steps. It was a good day. It was also a day with a hole in it, shaped exactly like the person who used to make the gravy and run the whole operation from the stove like a conductor, and we all stepped around the hole without naming it, and that, I decided, was allowed. Grief and gratitude are not enemies. They shared my table all winter, and mostly they minded their manners.
Christmas was harder, and simpler. I asked the kids, in early December, what they wanted it to look like — not the gifts, the shape of it — and Grace said, after thinking with her whole face, "Small. And nobody has to be brave." I have never been given better instructions for anything. We got a tree that leaned. Ethan untangled the lights with a patience I did not know he had and hung them without comment on the sagging strand. On Christmas Eve we ate off the good plates because Grace said the good plates were tired of being saved, and Paul called from Knoxville and stayed on speaker through the whole meal, eating his own dinner three hours east of us, close enough in every way that counted. I did not buy a gift for a wife, for the first time in nineteen years, and I noticed it, and I let myself notice it, and then I went to bed in a quiet house full of sleeping children and slept until morning. That was the gift, as it turned out. Sleep, in my own house, unafraid. A year earlier I would not have known how to ask Santa for that.
There was one more thing the winter asked of me, and it came through Ethan. His school counselor — the same woman who had called me in November — suggested, gently, that Ethan might benefit from talking to someone too, the way Grace did, given what he had seen and what he had done and the particular weight of being the one who had done it. I put it to him straight, the way I had learned to put everything to him. He was quiet for a moment, and then he said, "I don't think I need fixing, Dad. But I'll go once, if it makes the school feel better. And maybe once is enough to find out I'm wrong." He went three times. After the third he said the therapist had told him something he was still turning over: that there is a difference between watching people and watching over them, and that he had been doing the second one since he was sixteen, and that it was allowed to be tired. He told me this in the truck, looking out the windshield, in the manner of young men delivering classified information. "I'm not tired," he added. "But it's good to know it's allowed." I said it was. I said it was allowed for all of us, and we drove home through the dark with the radio low, and I thought about how my children were learning, in offices with fish tanks and in trucks and at kitchen tables, the lessons it had taken me forty-seven years and a catastrophe to learn: that love and vigilance are different things, and a house needs the first one and only sometimes the second.
Winter was the season of going through things. Not the case — the case had its own slow machinery and its own people, and Susan Park sent me summaries I read at the kitchen table and filed in the manila drawer. I mean the house. I mean my marriage. I mean the long, quiet audit a man does when he finally stops defending himself to himself.