Spring came with the trial still ahead of us like weather on a horizon — a date on a calendar, next spring's date now, set and reset and finally set, and I found I could look at it the way you look at any scheduled hard thing: with respect, and without letting it eat the days in front of it. Susan prepared. Priya prepared. I signed what I was asked to sign and answered what I was asked to answer and otherwise I built a sunroom in Brentwood for a couple who argued happily about tile, and I coached Grace through long division, and I watched Ethan shoot short, strange, beautiful films on his phone — the dog, the light on the water tower, Paul on a Sunday call laughing on speaker — and learn, frame by frame, the thing he had told me in the garage. Tell the truth late, but in time. He was practicing on us, and we let him, and the letting was part of the healing too, I think: a camera in our house that nobody had to fear, because everything it saw was allowed to be seen.
The patio I repaired myself, in April, on my knees, over two weekends. I had put it off for months with a craftsman's excuses — the stone had to be matched, the base had to be re-levelled where the frost had heaved it — but the truth was simpler and I knew it: one particular square of Tennessee limestone, out by the grill, was where a glass of sweet tea had shattered on my forty-seventh birthday, in front of thirty people, because my sixteen-year-old son had loved me faster than he could explain himself. The stone had kept a pale scar where the tea had gone into it and the shards had nicked the surface. I lifted that stone out myself. I levelled the base with my own hands, the way I had taught apprentices to do it for twenty years, sand and patience and a level laid three ways. I set a new stone — matched as well as stone can be matched, which is to say honestly different if you knew where to look — and I swept the sand into the joints and stood up with my knees cracking and looked at the whole patio, whole again, and understood that I had not erased anything. I had done the other thing. I had made the place strong enough to be used for its purpose again, which was people, standing around with plates in their hands, under lights, telling each other the truth at whatever speed they could manage.
There was a question Grace had been carrying, and it came out in April, on the repaired patio, with her telescope beside her and the cocoa going cold, in the careful voice she used for astronomy and for this. "If I wanted to write Mom a letter — not send it. Just write it. Would that be — is that allowed?" She did not look at me. She looked at Jupiter, which is to say she looked at the brightest thing available that was not my face. I took my time, because she had taken hers. "It's allowed," I said. "Writing is yours. Nobody — not me, not a judge, not anybody — gets a vote on what you write in your own notebook. Sending is a different question, and if that day ever comes, we'll talk about it then, together, and Dr. Osei can be part of it if you want. But writing? Grace. You are allowed every word you've got." She nodded at the sky for a while. Then she said, "I don't know if I want to. I just wanted to know if wanting to was bad." "It isn't bad," I said. "She's your mother. That's a fact with a lot of other facts standing next to it, and you're allowed to hold all of them at once. Grown people do it badly all the time. You're doing it fine." She wrote the letter, I believe — there was a notebook that lived in her desk drawer that spring and was not my business — and she never mentioned sending it, and I never asked. Some doors in that house we had learned to leave closed without locking, and some we left open without walking through, and knowing the difference, I had come to understand, was most of what a family is.
I thought about that conversation for a long time afterwards — about how my thirteen-year-old daughter, who had found me on a kitchen floor when she was twelve, could hold her mother in her mind as both the woman who read her bedtime stories and the defendant in a case with a date next spring, and refuse to let either fact evict the other. Ethan held his version of it differently — cleaner, angrier, with a filmmaker's instinct for the cut — and I held mine differently again, and none of us required the others to match. That, I decided, standing in my yard under my daughter's stars, was the thing Lauren had never understood and the thing the rest of us were learning in her absence: that the truth is not a single story you enforce. It is a table you keep setting, where every true thing gets a seat, even the ones that don't agree. Especially those.