Never Mock the Uniform

Chapter 12

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

That is the truth of the order to wait. It was the right order and it was a terrible order, and both of those things are true at the same time, and anyone who tells you otherwise was not there. I gave it because I believed the hidden threat was real, and the hidden threat was real, and the men lived because I gave it. And I have also lived with the knowledge that waiting is a kind of wound, and that the men who waited carry it, and that Ethan carries it most of all, because he was the one who had to stand in front of his soldiers and tell them to stay where they were while the ground closed around them.

Ethan tells the same decision the other way, and I am going to write his version down here exactly as he told it to me, because his version is also true, and I will not choose between them.

In his version, the decision that nearly got people killed was his own. He had wanted to advance. He had argued for it. He had looked at the same ground I had looked at and seen a gap instead of a trap, and he had been ready to take his soldiers through it. He believes now, six years later, that if he had been the one giving the orders that day, he would have led them straight into the killing ground, and that the only thing that stopped him was my order to wait. He says that plainly. He does not dress it up. He says he would have killed his own soldiers by doing the thing that felt right, and that I stopped him, and that he has never been able to decide whether to be grateful for that or to hate me for it.

But that is only the first half of his version. The second half is harder. In his version, my order cost lives. He says that the waiting itself killed people. Not in the way an ambush kills people, all at once and in the open, but in the slow way, the way exposure kills people, the way standing still in a place where the enemy is closing in kills people. He says there were men who died while we waited, men who might have lived if we had moved, men whose deaths belong to the order to hold position. He says the trap I was afraid of was real, and he says the waiting was also real, and he says both of them killed people, and he says I have to carry that the same way he carries his part of it.

I have listened to both versions, and I have not been able to make them into one story. In my version, the order to wait saved the unit. In his version, the order to wait cost lives. In my version, his instinct to advance would have walked them into a trap. In his version, his instinct was the right instinct of a good officer, and my order took it away from him, and the taking-away did its own damage. Both versions agree on the facts. The intelligence changed. The unit was surrounded. I ordered them to wait. The threat was hidden. Advancing would have meant crossing open ground. Men died anyway. Those facts are not in dispute. What is in dispute is what they mean, and six years has not settled it.

Ethan believes his choice nearly got people killed. I believe my order saved the people it saved and cost the people it cost. He believes that if he had moved, he would have killed his soldiers. I believe that if he had moved, the trap would have killed them, and that is a different thing, and he does not always see the difference. He believes that waiting was a failure of courage. I believe that waiting was the only courage available to us that day. We have had this conversation more than once, and it has never ended with either of us convinced, because there is no argument that can settle it. There is only the fact that we both made the decisions we made, and the men who did not come home did not come home, and the men who did come home did, and all of us have had to live with the shape of that.

I am writing both accounts here because I will not let one of them disappear. If I write only mine, Ethan's version is lost, and his version is the one that has kept him awake for six years. If I write only his, mine is lost, and mine is the one that kept the unit alive. The truth of Helmand is that both of them are true, and that they do not fit together, and that no amount of retelling will make them fit. The order to wait saved lives and cost lives. The decision to advance would have saved lives and cost lives. That is what war does to a decision. It splits it down the middle and hands each half to a different person to carry, and neither half is the whole story.

News in the same category

Never Mock the Uniform

45 Part