"And the letters?" I asked. "You forged them. You wrote a letter in my handwriting, and a letter in hers, and you sent them, and you made us both believe the other had left. How did you do it? How did you get the paper? How did you learn our handwriting?"
"I have known you since you were a boy, Sam," he said, and there was something almost sad in his voice. "I have seen your handwriting on a hundred birthday cards and thank-you notes. And Alice's handwriting was on every invitation and every card she ever sent to Rebecca, because they were friends, once, before all of this. It was not hard. It was not hard at all. And the letters you wrote to her, after she left, the ones you sent to her old address, the ones that came back unopened, I intercepted those, too. I had them forwarded to me. I have them still. They are in my study, in a drawer, and I have read them, every one of them, and I am sorry for that, and I am sorry for all of it, but I am not sorry for trying to protect my daughter."
"Protect her from what?" I asked, and my voice rose, and I did not care. "From love? From a man who loved her? From a life that would have been real? You did not protect her, Walter. You lied to her. You lied to me. You lied to Alice. You stole seven years from all of us, and you stole a father from a six-year-old boy, and you did it because you thought you knew better than we did. And you were wrong. You were wrong about all of it."
Walter looked at me, and for a moment, the mask slipped, and I saw what was underneath it, and it was not cruelty, and it was not malice, but something sadder and more ordinary, which was fear, and pride, and a man who had spent his whole life believing that money and control could fix anything, and who had just discovered that they could not.
***
Rebecca called off the wedding herself. She did it the way she did everything, with dignity, and with clarity, and without drama, and she did it in a letter to me, and in a conversation with her parents, and in a statement to the guests, all in the same day, and I admired her for it, even as my heart broke for her, because she deserved better than to have her wedding become the setting for someone else's truth.
Her letter to me was short, and it was kind, and it was honest. She wrote that she had loved me, and that she believed I had loved her, and that she believed we could have had a good life together, but that a good life built on someone else's lie was not a good life, and that she would not marry a man whose heart belonged, in part, to another woman and to a child, and that she did not blame me, and that she did not blame Alice, and that she blamed only her father, and that she was going to deal with him in her own way, and in her own time. And she wrote that she hoped, one day, we could be friends, and that she hoped I would find happiness, and that she hoped Leo would grow up knowing his father, and that she meant every word of it.
I read the letter twice, and I put it in the tin box, next to Alice's letter, and Leo's baby teeth, and the photograph of Alice and me on the beach, because it belonged there, with the other true things, the things that had been written honestly, by people who meant what they said.
Rebecca's conversation with her father was longer, and I was not there for it, and she told me about it later, in pieces, over coffee, in her gallery, where she sat among the paintings and the sculptures and the light coming through the big windows, and she told me that she had asked him why, and that he had given her the same reasons he had given me, and that she had listened, and that she had told