She told me about finding out she was pregnant, two months later, in a town two hundred miles away, in a clinic with pale green walls, and about how she had sat in the waiting room with her hands in her lap, and about how she had decided, in that moment, that she would keep the baby, and that she would raise him alone, and that she would never tell me, because she believed I had made my choice, and because she did not want her child to grow up knowing that his father had not wanted him.
She told me about the two jobs. She worked in a bookstore in the mornings, shelving books and helping customers, and she cleaned offices at night, after the people had gone home, pushing a cart down empty hallways, emptying trash cans, wiping desks. And in between, she drew. She drew on napkins, on the backs of receipts, on any paper she could find, and slowly, very slowly, she began to sell her drawings, first to the bookstore, then to a small publisher, then to a bigger one, and she began to illustrate children's books, and the books began to sell, and she began to make enough money to quit the night job, and then enough to quit the bookstore, and then enough to rent a small house with a yard, and to give Leo a room of his own, with a window that looked out on a tree where the birds came every morning.
And she told me about the pneumonia. Leo was four years old, and he got sick, very sick, in the middle of the night, and she took him to the hospital, and they kept him for nine days, and she sat beside his bed for nine days, and she did not sleep, and she did not eat, and she prayed, and on the ninth day, he turned a corner, and he got better, and when she went to the billing office, shaking, because she knew she could not pay, they told her the bill had already been paid, in full, by an anonymous donor, through a foundation. She had never known who it was. She had never understood it. She had only been grateful, and a little bit afraid, because anonymous kindness, in her experience, always had a reason.
I listened to all of it, and with every story, I felt the weight of what had been taken from us grow heavier, and I felt the anger grow, too, not at Alice, never at Alice, but at the man who had written those letters, and who had paid that bill, and who had sat in the front row of my wedding in a suit that cost more than my first car, and who had looked at a six-year-old boy walking down the aisle and known exactly who he was.
******
Noah Fletcher had been my best friend since the first week of college, when we had both shown up to the same architecture studio with the same cheap drafting tools and the same terror of being found out as frauds. He was the kind of person who, when you told him that your life had just fallen apart, did not ask you how you felt. He asked you what you needed. And when I told him, the morning after the wedding that was not a wedding, that I needed to understand how Walter Sloane had done what he had done, Noah said, "Then we find out. And we start with the letters."
We started with the letters. Alice still had hers, the one in my handwriting, folded into quarters and kept in a small tin box with Leo's baby teeth and a lock of his hair and a photograph of the two of us on the beach at Sullivan's Island, the sun going down behind us. She brought it to my studio, and she laid it on the drafting table, and we looked at it together, under the bright light, and I saw, for the first time, what I should have seen seven years ago. The handwriting was close to mine. It was very close. But it was not mine. The loops were wrong. My letters lean to the right when I write quickly, and these leaned to the left, just slightly, as if someone had studied my handwriting and copied it, carefully, and gotten almost everything right, and missed the one thing that would have given them away. And the paper was wrong, too. It was my paper, the thick cream paper I used for letters, but it was a different weight, a different shade, a shade lighter, as if someone had bought it from a different store, in a different year.