She wrote that she was leaving. She wrote that she had met someone else. She wrote that she did not love me anymore, and that she had not loved me for a long time, and that she was sorry, and that she hoped I would understand, and that she hoped I would find someone who could love me the way I deserved to be loved. It was short. It was cold. It was nothing like her. And I read it five times, and each time it made less sense, and each time it hurt more, and then I did the thing I have regretted more than anything else in my life. I believed it.
I believed it because it was in her handwriting, and because it was on her paper, and because I could not imagine any other explanation. I believed it because I was twenty-seven years old and I had never been left before, and I did not know how to fight for something I could not see. I wrote her back, three letters, and then five, and then I stopped, because she did not answer, and because the letters came back, eventually, unopened, marked as undeliverable, and I told myself that she had moved on, and that I should move on too, and I did, in the way that people do, by working too much, and by drinking too much, and by pretending, for seven years, that the pain had gone away, when all it had done was go quiet.
What I did not know, what I could not have known, was that Alice had never written that letter. What I did not know was that she had received a letter of her own, a letter in my handwriting, on my paper, telling her that I never wanted to see her again, that I had met someone else, that our life together had been a mistake. And what I did not know was that both letters had been written by the same hand, a hand that was not hers and not mine, a hand that belonged to Walter Sloane.
***
Rebecca found me in the garden an hour later, after the guests had gone, after the quartet had packed up and left, after the caterers had begun to carry the untouched food back to their trucks in silence. She was still in her wedding dress, and she had taken off her shoes, and she was walking barefoot on the stone path, and she looked, in that moment, more like herself than she had all day. She came and sat beside me on the bench under the oak tree, and she did not speak for a while, and I did not speak either, and we sat there together, two people who had almost gotten married, listening to the birds.
"My father did it," she said, finally, and her voice was very steady, and very tired. "I don't know all of it yet. But I know enough. I went to him, after you went outside, and I asked him, and he did not deny it. He said he was protecting me. He said he was protecting the family. He said Sam Whitaker was a nice boy but not the right kind of boy, not the kind of boy who belonged in our family, and that Alice Hart was a nice girl but not the right kind of girl, and that he had done what a father does. He said it as if he believed it. And maybe he does believe it. That is the worst part. I think he actually believes it."
I looked at her, and I saw the pain in her face, and I saw the anger underneath it, and I saw something else, too, something I had always admired about Rebecca, which was her honesty, the way she looked at things directly, even when they hurt. "Rebecca," I said, "I am so sorry. I am sorry for all of it. I am sorry I brought this into your wedding. I am sorry I did not know. I am sorry for what your father did, and I am sorry for what it cost you."
"Don't be sorry," she said. "Be angry. Be angry at him, not at yourself. You did nothing wrong. I did nothing wrong. Alice did nothing wrong. Leo did nothing wrong. The only person who did something wrong is my father, and he has been doing it for seven years, and he has been lying about it for seven years, and I am going to find out everything, and then I am going to decide what to do about it. But first, I need you to tell me one thing. Is it true? Is Leo your son?"
"Yes," I said. "I am sure of it. I can see my father in him. I can see Alice in him. And Alice would not lie about this. She came here today, after seven years, with a six-year-old boy, and she stood outside a chapel and waited. People do not do that unless it is true."