The room made a sound then, a low sound, a collective intake of breath, and Reverend Greene stepped forward, and he said, very gently, "Perhaps we should give the couple a moment of privacy. Perhaps everyone could step outside, into the garden, and give them some time." And the congregation, grateful for something to do, began to rise, and to move toward the doors, and to murmur to each other in low voices, and Noah came to my side, and he put his hand on my shoulder, and he said, "Sam. Talk to me. What the hell is going on?"
"I don't know yet," I said. "But I think I've been lied to for seven years, and I think Walter Sloane knows why."
Noah looked at Walter, and Walter looked back at him, and there was something in Walter's eyes, something I had never seen there before, something that looked very much like fear. And Noah said, very quietly, "Then we'll find out. Whatever it is, we'll find out."
***
I remembered the first time I saw Alice Hart. It was the fall of my second year at the College of Charleston, and I was sitting in the library, sketching a house I had been assigned to design for a class, and she was sitting across from me, drawing in a sketchbook, and she was drawing a bird, a cardinal, in colored pencil, and she was so focused on it that she did not notice me watching her for a full ten minutes. When she finally looked up, she caught me staring, and instead of being annoyed, she smiled, and she turned the sketchbook around so I could see, and she said, "He's a cardinal. His name is Reggie. He comes to my window every morning, and I think he is telling me something, but I haven't figured out what yet."
That was how it began. With a bird named Reggie, and a girl who drew him, and a boy who designed houses and had never met anyone who named the birds at her window. We were twenty years old, and we were certain about everything, and we were certain most of all about each other. We spent that winter in the library, and that spring on the Battery, watching the harbor, and that summer in a small apartment on Tradd Street, where she painted at the kitchen table and I built models of houses out of balsa wood, and we talked about the future as if it were a place we were already walking toward, hand in hand, and we made plans, the way young people do, with absolute confidence and no idea what the world could do to plans.
In the summer of our third year, I gave her the compass. It was my grandfather's, or it had been, and my father had given it to me when I turned eighteen, and I had carried it in my pocket through high school and through my first year of college, and I had never thought I would give it to anyone. But one evening, on the beach at Sullivan's Island, with the sun going down and the sky turning the color of a bruise, I took it out of my pocket, and I opened it, and I showed her the engraving, and I said, "My grandfather carried this when he was in the war. He said it always brought him home. And I want you to have it. I want you to keep it, and I want you to know that no matter where you go, no matter how far, you can always find your way back to me."
She took it, and she held it in her hand, and she looked at it for a long time, and then she looked at me, and she said, "I will never need it. Because I am never going anywhere." And I believed her. I believed her completely. And for three more years, I had no reason not to believe her.
***
The letter came on a Tuesday in October. I remember the day because it was raining, and the rain was coming down in the way it does in Charleston in October, hard and sudden, and I was in my studio, working on a set of drawings for a house on Kiawah Island, and the mail came, and there was a letter from Alice, in her handwriting, on the paper she always used, the thick cream paper with the small bird printed in the corner. I opened it standing up, and I read it, and I read it again, and I did not understand it, and then I understood it, and I wished I did not.