Diane Okafor did not believe in loud beginnings. That was one of the reasons I trusted her. Other lawyers I had met wanted a press conference before they wanted a fact. Diane wanted a list, a timeline, and a room with a door that closed. She sat across from me in her office on a Tuesday morning with a legal pad already half full in her neat, slanted handwriting and said, "If Kemp has been doing this for years, Isaiah, you were not the first. You were just the first one who walked into a store, asked for a manager, and walked out with video before anyone could tell him no. That makes you dangerous to him in a way the others never got to be. It also makes you the worst possible person to go knocking on doors."
I understood her before she finished. A colonel, in uniform or out of one, changes the temperature in a room. People either perform for you or hide from you, and neither gives you the truth. Diane said we would do it her way. Quietly. Through people who already knew people. Through Simone's church directory and Cameron's barbershop conversations and the kind of referrals that never looked like referrals at all. "We are not building a rally," she said. "We are building a record. One name at a time, and only if they want to be on it."
Simone gave us the first name in her kitchen, while Malik did homework at the table and pretended not to listen to every word. "Mr. Amos Whitfield," she said, keeping her voice low. "From Mount Zion. He sits two pews behind us, same gray suit every Sunday. Last spring he missed three Sundays in a row, and when he came back Pastor asked if he'd been sick. He said somebody kept cutting his tires. Twice in one month, at the VA clinic lot. People laughed a little because they thought he was exaggerating, or had hit a curb. He never laughed back." Malik looked up from his worksheet. "Is that the man with the cane who gives me mints?" Simone nodded. "Don't repeat grown folks' business at school, Malik." "I won't," he said, and went back to his numbers, filing it away the way children file everything they are told not to repeat.
Amos Whitfield lived in a small brick house six blocks from Simone, with a flagpole in the front yard and no flag on it because, he told me later, the rope had snapped in August and he had not yet trusted his knees on a ladder to fix it. He was seventy-eight, a former Army staff sergeant who had served two tours before I was born, and he opened his door in a cardigan and slippers and looked at me for a long moment before he said, "You're Simone's brother. The colonel." It was not a question. I said I was, and that I was not there in any official capacity, and that Diane, who stood a respectful step behind me on the porch, was a lawyer and not there to sell him anything. He studied her the way old soldiers study any new person near their perimeter, then stepped aside. "You might as well come in. The coffee's already made, and nobody drinks coffee alone in this house if I can help it."
His living room was immaculate in the way of a man who had lived alone since his wife died and had decided order was a form of respect for her memory. Photographs covered one wall, Amos in uniform, Amos at a wedding, Amos holding a grandchild who was now probably in college. He poured coffee into three mugs without asking whether we wanted any and sat in a chair that had molded itself to him over years. Diane did not open her notebook right away. She asked about the photographs. She asked about his service. She let him be a man before she let him be a witness, and I watched his shoulders come down by degrees.