Police Officer Slashed a Veteran’s Tire — He Had No Idea Who Was Watching

Chapter 30

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The council's response was everything Diane had predicted and still, somehow, disappointing in the particular way that predicted disappointments always are. Councilor Hayes thanked me for my service, a phrase I had come to hear as the beginning of a door closing, and said the matter was under review by the appropriate authorities and that the council had full confidence in the processes in place. Councilor Brandt said he hoped everyone would let the system work and not rush to judgment. Councilor Singh asked whether the chief reported to the council on internal matters or to the city manager, and was answered, by the city attorney, with a sentence containing the word ordinarily three times and no information at all. Two members examined their papers. One examined the clock.

Then the older councilwoman at the far end of the bench removed her reading glasses and leaned toward her microphone, and the temperature of the room changed.

Her name was Eleanor Voss. She was seventy-four years old, the longest-serving member of the council, a former school superintendent with a reputation, which I learned later was entirely earned, for reading every page of every document anyone had ever placed in front of her, including the pages they hoped she would skip. Diane had submitted, as part of a formal public comment packet delivered to each member that afternoon, the department's own complaint statistics as released under her records request, with her office's analysis of the gaps: complaints filed over five years, complaints sustained, complaints closed as unfounded within a single week of filing, complaints originating from certain neighborhoods and their outcomes compared to complaints from others, and the number of times in five years that an officer with three or more complaints in a twelve-month period had been returned to duty with no recorded intervention of any kind.

"Councilor Hayes," Mrs. Voss said, in the voice of a woman who had once run a building full of adolescents and feared nothing on earth, "I have read the packet submitted by Ms. Okafor's office. I would like to ask some questions about it, and I would like the answers to be as plain as the numbers are."

The chair shifted in his seat. "Councilor Voss, personnel matters are not within—"

"These are not personnel matters," she said. "These are totals. I did not learn the name of a single officer from this document. I learned that of one hundred and ninety-six complaints filed by citizens of this city over five years, nine were sustained. Nine. I learned that sixty-one complaints were closed within seven days of being filed. I would like someone to explain to me, in plain language, what an investigation that lasts less than a week consists of. I learned that complaints from the east side of this city were closed unfounded at more than twice the rate of complaints from the west side, and I would like to know whether anyone in this administration has ever noticed that before this week, and if they noticed it, what they did about the noticing. And I learned—" she put her glasses back on and found a line with one finger, with terrible precision "—I learned that in five years, fourteen officers accumulated four or more complaints each, and that the sum total of recorded discipline for those fourteen officers, in this document, is zero. Zero suspensions. Zero terminations. Zero letters of reprimand that this body has been shown. Now. I am an old woman, and I have sat on this council through four chiefs of police, and I have voted for every budget this department has ever asked me for. But I did not vote to fund a suggestion box. If these numbers are wrong, I want them corrected in public. If these numbers are right, I want to know what this council intends to do besides express confidence. Mr. Brooks asked for an independent investigation. I would like that request placed on the agenda of our next session, in writing, and I would like the chief of police present at that session to answer questions that are actually his to answer."

The silence after she finished was the fullest silence of the night. Hayes thanked her for her comments in a voice that suggested he would rather have thanked her for anything else. No vote was taken. No investigation was authorized. The gavel brought the session to a close on schedule, and the machinery of the city, confronted in public by its own arithmetic, did what machinery does. It adjourned.

But in the hallway afterward, three different citizens I had never met asked Mrs. Voss to repeat the numbers so they could write them down, and Priya Nair was writing faster than I had ever seen a person write, and a local television reporter asked Councilor Hayes, on camera, whether zero was an acceptable number, and Hayes walked past the camera without answering, and that non-answer led the eleven o'clock broadcast. Diane, gathering her papers in the corridor with the calm of a woman who has just watched a seed go into the ground, said, "Nothing happened tonight, and everything happened tonight. Remember both halves of that, because you'll need them."

We drove home in near silence, the three of us, through streets that were quieter than the chamber had been.

Malik was asleep on the neighbor's couch when Cameron carried him home, boneless the way children are when they trust the arms entirely, and Simone put him to bed while I sat at the kitchen table with a glass of water I did not drink, replaying Councilor Voss's voice saying zero into the record. Then Simone came back downstairs in her socks and stood in the kitchen doorway with her arms folded, and I knew from the whole history of my life with my sister that the conversation I had been dreading was no longer postponable.

News in the same category

Police Officer Slashed a Veteran’s Tire — He Had No Idea Who Was Watching

45 Part