Police Officer Slashed a Veteran’s Tire — He Had No Idea Who Was Watching

Chapter 29

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The council chamber was smaller than it looked on television and hotter, a low room with wood paneling and rows of chairs bolted in arcs facing a long raised bench, behind which the nine council members sat beneath the seal of the city and a pair of flags and a clock whose second hand I could hear in the silences. The room was full before the gavel. Veterans sat along the left wall, some in caps, some not. Officers, off duty and in plain clothes in a way that fooled no one, sat along the right. Amos Whitfield was there with his sister supporting his arm. Rosa Delgado was there with her husband. Priya Nair sat in the press row with her notebook. And ordinary citizens, the people a town is actually made of, filled every chair between the camps, people who had read a careful story on a Sunday and had come out on a Thursday night because staying home with their opinion had stopped being enough.

They took the whole agenda first. Zoning variances. A road resurfacing contract. A commendation for the high school robotics team, which received warmer applause than anything else that night and deserved it. I sat between Simone and Cameron and listened to the ordinary business of a city governing itself, and I took some comfort from it, genuinely, because that ordinary business was precisely the thing Kemp's knife had been aimed at. Not me. The idea that rules in this town applied going in every direction.

When the chair finally opened the floor to public comment on matters not on the agenda, there was a silence that lasted perhaps four seconds and felt like an hour.

I stood up.

I had spoken to rooms of soldiers in worse circumstances than this one. I had briefed generals, and stood in front of the families of men I was sending into places with names the news would never learn. None of that made my heart beat any slower as I walked to the microphone, adjusted it down an inch without thinking, and looked up at nine faces arranged in a row, most of them already composed into the expressions public men and women wear when they intend to endure a citizen rather than hear one.

"Good evening," I said. "My name is Isaiah Brooks. I live here part of the year with my sister's family on Elmwood Drive. I am a colonel in the United States Army, and I have served this country for twenty-two years. I am not here in that capacity. I am here as a resident, and as a complainant, and I will take less than my time."

I told them about the tire. I told it exactly as it had happened, in order, without adjectives doing any work that the facts could not do themselves. A uniformed officer, in daylight, in a hardware store parking lot on Mercer Avenue, with a knife, on camera. A complaint filed through the proper channels, in good faith, by a man who believed in proper channels the way other men believed in God. And then, while that complaint was under review, a second incident, at night, at my family's home, the same tire, the same method, captured on a clearer camera, the officer out of uniform but not, as the footage showed, out of his habits. I did not show the videos. The council had been sent copies through Diane's office that afternoon, and I said so, plainly, so that no member could later claim the evidence had been withheld from them. I watched two of the members glance down at the folders in front of them with the particular discomfort of men who had been handed something they could no longer pretend not to have.

"I am not asking this council to convict anyone tonight," I said. "That is not your job, and it is not what due process means, no matter how often that phrase is used in this matter as a shield instead of a standard. I am asking for three things that are entirely within your authority. An independent investigation, conducted by a body outside the department, of both incidents and of the decision to return the officer involved to full patrol duty after four days. A public accounting of the complaint process, so that citizens of this city can see how complaints against officers are received, investigated, and resolved. And protection, stated on this record, for every citizen who has filed or will file a complaint, from retaliation of any kind. That is all I am asking. I would observe only this. I have been trained, at considerable expense to the taxpayer, to notice when I am being watched and when I am being tested. Every citizen who comes before you in the future will be tested by what you do with this. They are watching now to learn whether a complaint in this city is a right or a risk. I would like them to learn that it is a right. Thank you."

I sat down. The room did not erupt. Rooms like that rarely do. But Simone's hand found mine on the chair between us and held it with a pressure I felt for the rest of the night, and down the left wall one of the veterans, Walter, the seventy-one-year-old from our porch, stood up alone and applauded once, twice, and then sat down again as if he had simply needed his body to register an opinion his voice could not improve on.

News in the same category

Police Officer Slashed a Veteran’s Tire — He Had No Idea Who Was Watching

45 Part