Police Officer Slashed a Veteran’s Tire — He Had No Idea Who Was Watching

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The department's answer arrived on Wednesday, and it arrived in the shape of Chief Ronald Vance standing behind a podium with flags behind him and the seal of the city polished to a shine on the wall.

We watched it on Simone's television, all of us, because Diane had called ahead and told us to watch it and to record it and to say nothing to anyone while it was happening. The chief was a big man gone soft in the middle, with silver hair cut close and a voice trained by thirty years of speaking to rooms that contained cameras. He expressed concern. He expressed commitment. He expressed the deepest possible respect for the men and women who put on the uniform every day in a difficult and dangerous time. He said the department took all complaints seriously and followed established procedures in every case without exception, and he said that the public should be cautious about drawing conclusions from partial videos circulated outside of the full context that only a complete investigation could provide.

"Partial videos," Cameron said to the television. "He's talking about a man on our driveway like it's a weather report."

"Let him talk," I said. "Every word is on the record now. That's worth something."

Chief Vance said that personnel matters were confidential under state law and departmental policy, that he could not discuss any individual officer, and that it would be irresponsible to do so. He said that the overwhelming majority of his officers served with honor. He said that anyone with information about any crime in the city, including vandalism, should report it through proper channels. He took three questions. To the first, about whether any officer had been disciplined, he said he could not comment on personnel matters. To the second, about whether the department believed its own officers were safe from false accusation, he said he stood behind his people, and a small, warm round of applause went through the room behind the podium, officers and union representatives and city staff, applauding their chief for standing behind them while my truck sat at the curb on a second ruined tire.

The third question came from a woman I did not yet know, dark-haired, unhurried, holding her phone up to record because the television cameras were all pointed the other way. She asked whether the chief could confirm that an officer currently under internal review had been returned to full patrol duty that week, and whether that was consistent with the procedures he had just described. The chief smiled the patient smile of a man who has survived a thousand press conferences, and said that staffing decisions were operational and confidential, and that the department's commitment to due process applied to everyone, officers and citizens alike. Then he thanked everyone and stepped away from the podium while the flags stood still behind him.

Diane's information, passed to us that afternoon through her investigator, was plainer than the chief's language. Kemp had been placed on desk duty for four days. Four days of answering phones and filing reports in a room without windows, which the department could describe, if anyone asked, as administrative reassignment pending review. On the fifth day, citing staffing shortages and a preliminary finding that the available evidence was inconclusive, he had been returned to full duty. Full duty. A badge, a cruiser, a patrol route that took him, by coincidence or design, down streets where Amos Whitfield got his hair cut and where Jaylen had been stopped walking home with groceries, and within a few blocks, always, of Simone's front yard.

Inconclusive, Diane said, was the word they were sheltering behind. The first video was grainy enough to house an argument. The second video had not yet, officially, been authenticated, and the department was in no hurry to authenticate it, because authentication was the hinge everything else swung on.

"So he slashes my brother's tire on camera in my driveway," Simone said, when Diane explained this to us in her office with the door closed, "and the official word is inconclusive?"

"The official word," Diane said, "is whatever the official word has to be until somebody with a printing press or a gavel decides otherwise. Which brings me to the next conversation we need to have, and it's a conversation about the press, and about you, Isaiah, deciding how public you are willing to become. Because once we go public, we do not get to go back, and neither does your family, and I need everyone in this room to understand that with their eyes open."

Simone looked at me. Cameron looked at the floor and then, deliberately, at Diane.

"Tell us what going public actually does," Cameron said. "Not the idea of it. The mechanics."

"It does two things," Diane said. "It makes it much harder for the department to bury this in a personnel file, because now voters and council members and the state are watching the file. And it makes your house a subject of public conversation, which means strangers will have opinions about your family at full volume. Both of those things are true at once, and they stay true at once. There is no version where you get the first without the second."

The journalist's name was Priya Nair, and Diane chose her the way she chose everything in this case, carefully and for reasons she was willing to explain. Priya wrote for the city's paper of record. She had covered the police beat for six years. She had a reputation, Diane said, for refusing to print what she could not verify and for sitting on a story for weeks rather than getting it wrong in a hurry, and in a case like ours, that reputation was worth more than speed or sympathy.

News in the same category

Police Officer Slashed a Veteran’s Tire — He Had No Idea Who Was Watching

45 Part