He left Marcus's office with a list of things to do and a feeling in his chest like a weight he could not put down. He drove home slowly, and he thought about Renee, about the letter, about the way she had tried to protect Kayla from a woman she had barely known, and he thought about how much Renee had seen that he had missed. He thought about the day he had met Brittany, about how she had come into his life at exactly the moment when he was loneliest, when Kayla was four and asking questions about her mother that he did not know how to answer, when the house felt too big and too quiet, and he wondered now whether that had been an accident. He wondered whether Brittany had known exactly what she was doing when she came into their lives, whether she had seen a widowed father and a little girl who needed a mother and understood, at once, that they were the perfect family for her to step into. He did not want to believe that. He wanted to believe that she had loved him, that she had loved Kayla, that the hair and the papers and the letter were all misunderstandings that could be explained. But the letter was in his bag, and the papers were in Marcus's office, and the curls were gone, and he could not make those three things into a misunderstanding no matter how hard he tried.
That evening, after Kayla was asleep, he sat in the study and went through every drawer in the house. He found more papers than he expected, a stack of them, forms and authorizations and permissions, and he put them all in a box to take to Marcus. Some of them he remembered signing. Some of them he did not remember at all, and that frightened him more than the ones he remembered, because it meant there were moments in his own life, in his own house, when he had signed his name without even noticing. He thought about Caroline then, because Caroline was the woman who had introduced Brittany to him, and he realized that Caroline was the one person who knew Brittany from before, from before Darius, from before Kayla, and that if anyone could tell him who Brittany really was, it was Caroline.
Caroline had raised Brittany's biological daughter. Darius knew that much, because Brittany had told him once, early on, in a conversation he had half forgotten, that Caroline had taken in a little girl years ago, a child who needed a home, and that Caroline was a good woman for doing it. He had never asked whose child it was. He had never thought to ask. It had sounded like a kindness, a woman raising a child who was not her own, and he had admired Caroline for it without ever wondering where the child had come from. Now, sitting in the study with the box of papers beside him and Renee's letter in his pocket, he wondered why he had never asked, and he understood that there were questions he had not asked because he had not wanted to know the answers, and that the time for not asking was over.
He called Caroline the next morning, and he asked if he could come and see her, and she said yes, in a voice that told him she had been expecting the call, or something like it, for a long time. He drove to her house with the folder in his bag, and he sat at her kitchen table, and he told her about the letter, and about the papers, and about Kayla's hair, and he asked her, plainly, what she knew about Brittany that he did not know. Caroline looked at him for a long time, and then she looked out of the window at the garden, and then she looked back at him, and she told him the secret.
Caroline told him that before Kayla was born, before Darius had ever met Brittany, Brittany had given birth to a daughter of her own. A baby girl. She had carried that child and given birth to her, and then she had given her up for adoption, and she had never gone back for her. Caroline had raised that child. The little girl Brittany had once mentioned, the one Caroline had taken in out of kindness, was Brittany's own daughter, and Brittany had never told Darius any of it. Not when they met. Not when they got engaged. Not when she moved into his house and started making decisions about his daughter. She had kept it from him completely, as if it had never happened, as if the child had never existed, and Caroline had kept the secret too, because Brittany had asked her to, and because Caroline had believed, for a long time, that it was Brittany's story to tell.